Avengers # 51

[NYNick]

?

 

 

[ROBTOTHEC]

Just my humble opinion, but two things.

You shouldn't put the grades up you are thinking, let the

members look and decide for you without trying to sway opinions.

As for the book you have up, do you really think it could get a 7.0?

 

There is a long color breaking crease through the lettering about

4-5". A FINE is defined with no significant creasing.

I also see numerous color braking spine stress lines as well as

wear along the top edge and bottom edge.

The corners are blunted and a lot of soiling on the back.

I believe this would get a 4.5/5.0 if graded.

But, keep posting. It's the only way you will learn and get better!!

 

 

 

 

 

 

[marvelcollector]

With that large CB crease, I'd say 5.0...

 

And you shouldn't mention what you think the grade is...don't want to influence those offering opinions...

[NYNick]

Just my humble opinion, but two things.

You shouldn't put the grades up you are thinking, let the

members look and decide for you without trying to sway opinions.

As for the book you have up, do you really think it could get a 7.0?

 

There is a long color breaking crease through the lettering about

4-5". A FINE is defined with no significant creasing.

I also see numerous color braking spine stress lines as well as

wear along the top edge and bottom edge.

The corners are blunted and a lot of soiling on the back.

I believe this would get a 4.5/5.0 if graded.

But, keep posting. It's the only way you will learn and get better!!

 

 

 

 

 

[MR SigS]

You've been so kind to grade many of my scans, but I have to agree that 5.0-5.5 is likely.