Blue Beetle 2 (1st Question)

[JasonNewcomb]

 

 

 

Additional details:

 

 

 

 

 

Last page has a pretty nasty tear:

 

 

Everything else looks pretty good though:

 

 

 

[MR SigS]

That last page tear looks like a production flaw to me

I'd guess 7.5-8.0

[JasonNewcomb]

That last page tear looks like a production flaw to me

I'd guess 7.5-8.0

 

Hmmm, I was thinking 6.0 because of the miscut. Do miscuts appear in grades above 7?

[KPvD2011]

The bindery defect IMHO doesn't degrade the book to a 6.0...7.5 and 8.0 do allow a limited accumulation of minor bindery/printing defects (with the miscut being such a minor defect IMHO)

 

With the cover defects, tear on the FC and the BC, however,the book grades 5.5 IMHO

[JasonNewcomb]

The bindery defect IMHO doesn't degrade the book to a 6.0...7.5 and 8.0 do allow a limited accumulation of minor bindery/printing defects (with the miscut being such a minor defect IMHO)

 

With the cover defects, tear on the FC and the BC, however,the book grades 5.5 IMHO

 

I'd be happy with that! It looks pretty is the main thing.

[JasonNewcomb]

And thank you by the way.

[JasonNewcomb]

With the cover defects, tear on the FC and the BC, however,the book grades 5.5 IMHO

 

Hang on. That's not a tear on the FC. I just noticed you said that. It looks like a tear in that pic but it isn't.

[Peter Loves Gwen]

The back cover tear, and the edge down from that being bent back, is the worst defect. I'll say give it a 6.0-6.5 grade. The rest looks very solid and well above F+.

[JasonNewcomb]

The back cover tear, and the edge down from that being bent back, is the worst defect. I'll say give it a 6.0-6.5 grade. The rest looks very solid and well above F+.

 

Thank you Peter.

[KPvD2011]

With the cover defects, tear on the FC and the BC, however,the book grades 5.5 IMHO

 

Hang on. That's not a tear on the FC. I just noticed you said that. It looks like a tear in that pic but it isn't.

 

But on the BC is a tear right? IMHO it drops it below 6.0 (it would do so for me at least)....

[JasonNewcomb]

With the cover defects, tear on the FC and the BC, however,the book grades 5.5 IMHO

 

Hang on. That's not a tear on the FC. I just noticed you said that. It looks like a tear in that pic but it isn't.

 

But on the BC is a tear right? IMHO it drops it below 6.0 (it would do so for me at least)....

 

Yes, two tears in fact. One slight one and the other a small one.

 

Thank you.