ROUND 5 : Guess The Grade!!!

[PedigreeMan]

9.6

[Warlord]

9.6

 

BRC on the FC looks off... tempting to go 9.4. But I'm thinking everything else looks solid enough, plus the bronze age bonus points... that it'll make 9.6.

[rjpb]

9.6

[Calamerica]

9.8

 

CAL

[Stronguy]

9.4

--Stronguy

[nik]

Round 5 is now CLOSED. As you can tell from Round 6 it just got a little harder, time for people to start making their moves.

 

I will Update the Standing through 5 Rounds shortly.

Thanks for playing....

[NewtSamson]

(takes a bow)

I was the first one in this thread to call it a 9.6

so everyone ought to stop newbie hatin the newt man

[joe_collector]

(takes a bow)

I was the first one in this thread to call it a 9.6

 

Methinks some people should not draw attention to this fact.

[supapimp]

i don't read other forumites grades in these what's the grade threads, i call them like i see them.

[Mr. Zipper]

i don't read other forumites grades in these what's the grade threads, i call them like i see them.

 

I let the image load and make my call before I scroll down.

[joe_collector]

i don't read other forumites grades in these what's the grade threads, i call them like i see them.

 

WHOOSH, right over your head.

[supapimp]

[FFB]

First time in my life I've ever seen Calamerica overgrade a scan of a book on here. Someone write down the date.

 

Hi Cal.

[Aces]

WooHoo!

Another one right on the money!

[Calamerica]

Yeah, you caught me red-handed !

 

I was a tad unsure of NM 9.6 or NM 9.8 as I could find nothing wrong with the comic book( great comic btw). I "gambled" on the 9.8 because I could find nothing wrong( defect of any notice). But that is ok I was only .2 off - but believe me I want to always try to improve my grading skills. While I am thinking about it the lower grades IMO ARE harder to grade. Not so hard to grade a comic that is close to perfect except ONE area: the NM- 9.2 vs. the other NM levels. A lot of disagreements arise in that arena. A lot is at stake as the NM- 9.2's just cannot command the premiums the 9.4 and higher can. That fact is on a lot of CGC traders' minds.

 

later,

 

CAL