ASM 10

[TheUrologist]

By docparnes at 2012-04-12

 

By docparnes at 2012-04-12

 

This book has been pressed. Has a small 1mm x 2 mm chip out of one of the interior page edges.

[oakman29]

4.0 must have had a serious spine roll with that much of the pages showing.

[TheUrologist]

Actually, I thought it was married cover, but its actually just a miscut of 2-3 interior pages (full pages across) that are longer. no roll. Should change your grade...

[TheUrologist]

that or someone married non centerfold interior pages... but I dont think so.

[oakman29]

no still 4.0

[TheUrologist]

I almost want to grade this now. I was way higher. My thinking was solid 6.5, 7 on a very lucky day. This book is flat as can be and great gloss. no exterior tears. Some spine stresses and the readers crease. Not sure what to do with the interior chip and misaligned interior pages. Book in hand, if it graded a 4, it would be an incredible 4.0.

[oakman29]

If the missing pieces on the interior were not there,could be a 5.0

[TheUrologist]

Oak I appreciate the FB. This is why I'm putting my stuff up. I always seem to get 1-2 suprises when I submit. I appreciate the help (I hope I'm not coming across as defensive).

[oakman29]

Oak I appreciate the FB. This is why I'm putting my stuff up. I always seem to get 1-2 suprises when I submit. I appreciate the help (I hope I'm not coming across as defensive).

No of course not,really it's not a perfect system grading from a scan.Really we are just guessing at best,even though we think we know what CGC grades will be.

[TheUrologist]

usually I do a tarot reading and quick divination before final submission.

[oakman29]

usually I do a tarot reading and quick divination before final submission.