• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

CLOSED......THANKS!!

Started by Top City Comics,

36 posts in this topic

Wipple

Wipple

Posted
Posted

they were probably just submitted without provenance. i am not sure of the procedure to have them coded after the fact. i assume someone or some committee need to conclude it is in fact a pedigree copy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Wipple

Wipple

Posted
Posted

 

Please note that the purchase of an uncertified pedigree book from any collector or dealer does not obligate CGC to recognize the book in question as a pedigree copy.

 

 

If you are the current owner of a collection that you feel might be a pedigree, CGC is more than happy to discuss the potential pedigree status with you. Please feel free to call and ask to speak to a Pedigree Specialist.

 

from the CGC website

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dale Roberts

Dale Roberts

Posted
Posted
So you just think they are by eyeballing em? Must be a trained professional!

 

That "SN" is a pretty good indicator. (thumbs u

 

#10 and #11 are definitely Cookeville copies. Pretty well known collection. I have explained the provenance before on here. Found by Harry Thomas of Nashville, financed by Geppi, several of the books were purchased by Bob Overstreet. Big GA collection, including Captain America #1, and full runs of many titles.

 

To get a better detail, you can use the search function. Might be a year or so back though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
ChasingKingKirby

ChasingKingKirby

Posted
Posted
So you just think they are by eyeballing em? Must be a trained professional!

 

That "SN" is a pretty good indicator. (thumbs u

 

#10 and #11 are definitely Cookeville copies. Pretty well known collection. I have explained the provenance before on here. Found by Harry Thomas of Nashville, financed by Geppi, several of the books were purchased by Bob Overstreet. Big GA collection, including Captain America #1, and full runs of many titles.

 

To get a better detail, you can use the search function. Might be a year or so back though.

 

Dale,

 

Prolly been covered before, but any idea why CGC doesn't acknowledge the Ped?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Dale Roberts

Dale Roberts

Posted
Posted
So you just think they are by eyeballing em? Must be a trained professional!

 

That "SN" is a pretty good indicator. (thumbs u

 

#10 and #11 are definitely Cookeville copies. Pretty well known collection. I have explained the provenance before on here. Found by Harry Thomas of Nashville, financed by Geppi, several of the books were purchased by Bob Overstreet. Big GA collection, including Captain America #1, and full runs of many titles.

 

To get a better detail, you can use the search function. Might be a year or so back though.

 

Dale,

 

Prolly been covered before, but any idea why CGC doesn't acknowledge the Ped?

 

Not really. Maybe too much middle grade stuff. You would probably have to ask them. Never posed the question.

 

Personally, I don't really think it matters. In my opinion, pedigrees don't matter that much anymore, with the exception of the Mile High pedigree. To me, a 9.4 book with great eye appeal and white pages, is equal to another 9.4 book with equal eye appeal, and the same characteristics. I don't understand why anyone would pay significantly more to know who the original owner of the book was. Every book had an original owner at some point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top City Comics

Top City Comics

Posted
  • Author
Posted

:news: MOVING MOST OF THESE BOOKS TO EBAY TONIGHT!!:news:

 

:baiting: MAKE ME YOUR BEST OFFER SO I DON'T HAVE TO RELIST!! :wishluck:

 

RECAP

 

PAGE 1

Action 113 cgc 5.5 $190

All-Star #25 cgc 3.5 $245

All-Star #31 cgc 6.5 $460

Comic Cavalcade #1 cgc 4.5 $2250 OBO MOVED TO EBAY

Comic Cavalcade #10 cgc 7.0 $615 Cookeville Copy MOVED TO EBAY

Comic Cavalcade #11 ccg 9.2 $1675 OBO Cookeville Copy MOVED TO EBAY

Green Lantern #12 cgc 4.0 $340 1st Gambler

 

PAGE 2

Green Lantern #13 cgc 5.0 $400

Marvel Family #15 cgc 7.5 $130 MOVED TO EBAY

Popular Comics #137 cgc 9.0 $65 File Copy

Star-Spangled #26 cgc 8.0 $620

Superman #100 cgc 3.0 $320 Anniversary Issue

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Go to topic listing