Would you resubmit a CGC 9.4 comic?

[rabidwolf]

Just want to get a general idea from board members about whether they would resubmit a silver or bronze comic of strong market value(lets say 500 and up) if you believed it had a shot at a higher grade.

1. Is this too big a risk to take, since a little bit of damage such as when removing it from the slab or during shipping can drop the grade, or if the book had initially received 9.4 form two graders and a 9.2 from the other one may now receive two 9.2s and one 9.4.

2. Under what situation would you take the risk?

[blowout]

Under what situation would you take the risk?

 

1. If I thought the book had a chance to grade out higher

2. I owned an industrial press.

 

[Aman619]

2. Under what situation would you take the risk?

 

Immediately after my bank informs me that Steve Borock has cashed my check for $1000 and I have chuckled to his cryptic but grateful voicemail thank you call!! And by the way, your scenario is baded on a false premise: my book is a 9.6, not a 9.4..... Right Stevie baby?

 

[Aman619]

2. Under what situation would you take the risk?

 

Immediately after my bank informs me that Steve Borock has cashed my check for $1000 and I have chuckled to his cryptic but grateful voicemail thank you call!! And by the way, your scenario is baded on a false premise: my book is a 9.6, not a 9.4..... Right Stevie baby?

 

 

hey, who else here is unsatisfied with the 'lol' graemlin besided me?

(and where does that word come from??)

 

When I type 'lol' its to make the reader aware that I made a joke, to take what I say lightly. but to this graemlin generator, it comes out as that grinning hyena icon. And when I 'read' that icon in others' posts, it reads like a sarcastic "yer an acschole" laugh, head cocked back roaring with laughter.

 

anyone else want a simply "chuckling" icon??

Or am just to (sniff) sensitive??

[goldust40]

2. Under what situation would you take the risk?

 

Immediately after my bank informs me that Steve Borock has cashed my check for $1000 and I have chuckled to his cryptic but grateful voicemail thank you call!! And by the way, your scenario is baded on a false premise: my book is a 9.6, not a 9.4..... Right Stevie baby?

 

 

hey, who else here is unsatisfied with the 'lol' graemlin besided me?

(and where does that word come from??)

 

When I type 'lol' its to make the reader aware that I made a joke, to take what I say lightly. but to this graemlin generator, it comes out as that grinning hyena icon. And when I 'read' that icon in others' posts, it reads like a sarcastic "yer an acschole" laugh, head cocked back roaring with laughter.

 

anyone else want a simply "chuckling" icon??

Or am just to (sniff) sensitive??

 

What about this graemlin? Much friendlier.

[Aman619]

still looks a little evil, dont ya think?

im thinking its MY interpretation of when to say l o l thats out of sync...

"laugh out loud" implies just what that icon illustrates....

 

so maybe I should just and bear it!

[Mr. Zipper]

hey, who else here is unsatisfied with the 'lol' graemlin besided me?

(and where does that word come from??)

 

Yes... it does seem to be a mocking, derisive laugh out loud, doesn't it?

 

Maybe that's why I like it so much

 

Kinda reminds me of Robert DeNiro in the remake of Cape Fear... the over-the- top, manic laughter in the movie thaeter.

[uclapeterg]

I would never do it.