PGM Conan the Barbarian 24

[nevermind]

Bought this on my phone from Ebay, couldn't see all the little tears (mostly on the back). Opinions always appreciated. I'll let you know what grade it was advertised after a few replies. Thanks in advance. -Steve

 

 

[nevermind]

bigger scans -

 

 

[MR SigS]

5.5

[crassus]

7.0

[vaillant]

I would say at least a F+ 6.5, if cover lies flat. It’s hard to judge the small rips, but I think no less than F 6.0 even with them.

What a beautiful BWS cover, Windsor-Smith was kicking into high gear!

[Hado]

6.5 however I wouldn't be shocked at a 7.0. I'm going to guess they told you it was an 8.5.

[nevermind]

Thanks everybody. Advertised as 9.0.............. stupid Iphone. I have to take some of the blame, they did provide a good scan. I was just being lazy. -Steve

[zuulioso]

It is the two tears that do it in the most

[MODOK]

Thanks everybody. Advertised as 9.0.............. stupid Iphone. I have to take some of the blame, they did provide a good scan. I was just being lazy. -Steve

 

I guess when buying comic books on iPhone, you have to be diligent. I provide SUPER BIG scans with the comic books I sell on eBay. I don't like to put CGC numerical grades on my books since I'm not a CGC grader. However, I will give a tight grade range in the title and description.

Since you feel the seller overgraded, are you going to blast his feedback and DSRs? Yikes! You bought this for $19.99 from eBay seller bronze! on the 1st October and it is a nice copy IMO.

 

[Hado]

I grade books here on my iPhone all the time

[nevermind]

No, I wont blast him with bad feedback, but I think a flat VF would have been a more honest way to describe the book. With that said, I think it was an okay price for the grade and, like I said could have gone on the computer and checked the scan. Was just being lazy. -Steve

[MODOK]

No, I wont blast him with bad feedback, but I think a flat VF would have been a more honest way to describe the book. With that said, I think it was an okay price for the grade and, like I said could have gone on the computer and checked the scan. Was just being lazy. -Steve

 

Hey Steve! Good to know you won't punish him badly for his overgrade. You're taking a bit of responsibility by admitting you didn't spend the time to go to a large screen computer and check out the scan. I like your honesty. (thumbs u

[vaillant]

Yes, book looks actually good, without the small rips could have easily been in the VF+ range, but not a VF/NM as the sellers seem to have listed it.

I would be very careful in buying books advertised over NM-/NM on eBay, since unless there is a proper photo documentation it’s very easy to misjudge.

 

Anyway, I think you got a cool book, and if the price is OK who cares about the little rips, and… on the back cover? Aww, who gives a darn!