PGM: ASM 43

[bighairjer]

There is a very small tear (hole) on front cover between the D and E of Spider. What do you think? Thanks in advance!!

 

 

[Mmanick]

I'd go a 8.5 maybe the lowest an 8.0. That's a nice book

[MR SigS]

I really don't see much wrong with it. If not for the hole I'd call this a 9.4, so maybe 9.0?

 

Awesome book, it's a darned shame it has that defect

 

 

BTW, are you altering the image in some way? (color or contrast)

The colors seem a bit faded, especially on the Rhino's face. I'm asking because

ordinary color fade from sunlight usually goes for the red hues first. Just curious.

[vaillant]

Sweet, I’d call it a 9.0 as well…

[jimbo_707]

Sweet, I’d call it a 9.0 as well…

It's an attractive book, but I don't agree that you can have a hole in 9.0. I would grade it 7.5, VF-.

[Mailman_Comics]

My very first 12 cent comic, bought it at Dreamwell comics in Las Vegas for $20, it didn't look nearly as good as this one though. I agree, that ignoring the mention of the hole (which I can barely see) I'd have it at a 9.2/9.4. Not sure how much that whole will knock it down, awesome comic though (thumbs u

[Lost]

That's why CGC doesn't post their standards

Sweet, Id call it a 9.0 as well

It's an attractive book, but I don't agree that you can have a hole in 9.0. I would grade it 7.5, VF-.

 

That's why CGC doesn't post their standards so people can't say this. This would be a CGC 8.5/9.0.