CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 5

[thirdgreenham]

Here's the books for Round 5. Good luck, everyone!

 

 

Journey Into Mystery #50 Off-White to White Pages

 

 

 

Showcase # 28 Off-White to White Pages

 

 

[gradejunky]

I gotta see the results for round 4 before I even really look at these.

[NinjaSealed]

Grades in, since I graded low every round I drank a beer before I graded.

[John R]

Grades sent.

[dc eng]

PM Sent.

[thunsicker]

Wild guesses flung.

[sckao]

 

One of the preceding four contestants actually did well.... but which one?

 

 

[frozentundraguy]

No point dawdling and being on the "grade it now, time is running out" list. Grades sent.

[MR SigS]

Andy, are the books in this contest recently graded slabs or do their grade dates vary? Not sure it matters, but I'm curious.

 

 

 

[thunsicker]

One of the preceding four contestants actually did well.... but which one?

 

 

Great. Does that mean that three of the previous contestants did poorly?

 

[zuckuss2003]

That showcase was TOUGH! Guesses sent.

[WEBHEAD]

Grades Sent

 

 

 

 

 

[thirdgreenham]

Andy, are the books in this contest recently graded slabs or do their grade dates vary? Not sure it matters, but I'm curious.

 

 

 

How about I tell you after the contest? (thumbs u

 

Your job right now, is to grade the books in front of you.

 

 

[Cimm]

Grades thrown at the wall of indecision... Maybe this time they'll stick

[miraclemet]

Looks like the bottom of the JIM front cover got cut off the scan/image.

 

Im just gonna assume its condition is consistent with the rest of the book?

 

not that it would matter unless someone wrote the cgc grade at the bottom of the cover, my grading is all over the place!

[Timely]

Looks like the bottom of the JIM front cover got cut off the scan/image.

 

Im just gonna assume its condition is consistent with the rest of the book?

 

not that it would matter unless someone wrote the cgc grade at the bottom of the cover, my grading is all over the place!

 

Part of the right edge too.

[thirdgreenham]

Looks like the bottom of the JIM front cover got cut off the scan/image.

 

Im just gonna assume its condition is consistent with the rest of the book?

 

not that it would matter unless someone wrote the cgc grade at the bottom of the cover, my grading is all over the place!

 

Part of the right edge too.

 

 

Damn sorry, guys.

 

I PROMISE, the 2nd year I will not make these mistakes again. Maybe some other different kinds of mistakes, but not these ones.

[Scrooge]

Noticed that too. Didn't prevent me from grading it After all if that ST was a 9.0 & the Bats 17 was a 3.5, we are trying to grade a moving target

[MR SigS]

Andy, are the books in this contest recently graded slabs or do their grade dates vary? Not sure it matters, but I'm curious.

 

 

 

How about I tell you after the contest? (thumbs u

 

Your job right now, is to grade the books in front of you.

 

 

Fair enough. I wasn't sure how much of a factor this might be.

 

Great contest and great choices for the books. It really has been an education on how 10c books are/were graded.

 

[THB]