CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest Round 6

[thirdgreenham]

Welcome to Round 6 of 10! Thanks for staying with us. (thumbs u

 

This round is over on Monday night (May 13th) at 10:00 PM Eastern Time.

 

 

 

 

[thirdgreenham]

BOOK 11: Mystery In Space #43 Off-White to White Pages likely has a detached bottom staple.

 

 

 

BOOK 12: Startling Comics #33 Off-White Pages (Tape on interior cover & centerfold)

 

[Hibou]

That's it!

 

I'm going to start using Wizard Grading.

 

22.5 on the first book and Orange on the second!

[John R]

Grades sent.

[thirdgreenham]

Hold up, everyone. It's been brought to my attention that the Mystery In Space #43 may have a detached bottom staple.

 

I had a closer look at the book in the slab and I cannot see the staple. Here are some close up pics.

 

For those that have already submitted grades for this particular book, you may send me another PM with your revised grade. Do not edit your original post with grades, just send me another one that says "revised".

 

Of course, you don't have to revise your grade for this book, but I wanted to give the quick graders an equal opportunity as the slow ones. (thumbs u

 

 

 

[thirdgreenham]

Finally, a challenge for you guys, eh? Good practice to see how much CGC takes off for a detached staple.

[Jester Hats]

Am I allowed to skip grading the first book? I'm confused as hell with that "discovery" of a "possibly detached staple".

[Aces]

Am I allowed to skip grading the first book? I'm confused as hell with that "discovery" of a "possibly detached staple".

So you'll take a 0 to avoid a potential -1....

[Jester Hats]

Am I allowed to skip grading the first book? I'm confused as hell with that "discovery" of a "possibly detached staple".

So you'll take a 0 to avoid a potential -1....

I'm just asking. I'll probably throw a grade at it anyway.

[Timely]

Finally, a challenge for you guys, eh? Good practice to see how much CGC takes off for a detached staple.

 

I know!

[ashsaytr]

grades in!

[WEBHEAD]

[Jeffro.]

That's it!

 

I'm going to start using Wizard Grading.

 

22.5 on the first book and Orange on the second!

 

[THB]

Grades in...thanks for the help Mom......and no C+ is not a comic grade....

 

[Dannyboy0076-migration]

Grades in.

 

Here are the grades for 11 & 12!

 

Book 11: Boot heel

 

Book 12: Radiator cap

 

Should i put up a spoiler warning? Here are my sum total of results so far:

 

Horse sheet

 

But this game is fun!!

[pwog]

Grades submitted.

[Comicdey]

grades submitted

 

[WEBHEAD]

Too bad it is not secured with TAPE

[pwog]

I think Andy is mocking me.

[Spidey-fan73]

Hey, did I miss something??? 3 pics of the staple pull for book 11 and a description of book 12, no visual???

 

----

Never mind, some editing must have taken place as the pics have just materialized... or someone is playin shenanigans!!