A little help grading silver age.

[jayvegas420]

I'd like a cross-section of grade estimates for this silver aged book, as I do not hold many of them in my hand very often.

ASM #43 (Front)

ASM #43 (back)

ASM#48(front)

ASM #48(back)

Thanks for any time or feedback you may have for me.

 

[Stronguy]

I'd give it a FN+ 6.5 or maybe even a FN/VF 7.0. Nice looking book.

[Tango 'n Cash]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

[FFB]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

He had so much fun last time, he wants to do it again.

 

I grade the book a 2.0 due to the strong odor of shiite. The odor results from the fact that the book has been owned by an arsehole for some time.

[jayvegas420]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

I see you lost track of the threads for a sec. but, I was talking about the opinons reflecting the character and shaddyness of board members. When I ask for a guess on a grade I never lash out at that, I take it for what it is an opinion on the condition of a book. But when people go as far to "garuntee" that certain reserves won't be met and certain issues will be returned due to poor grading, I think it I am within my rights to at least contest their opinions, especially when they are later "proven" wrong.

Secondly when people attack the integrity of strangers who they have never done business with, I will defend that to no end. as would anyone with strng character and a perfect track record.

 

Thanks for the grade by the way

[jayvegas420]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

He had so much fun last time, he wants to do it again.

 

I grade the book a 2.0 due to the strong odor of shiite. The odor results from the fact that the book has been owned by an arsehole for some time.

 

Case in point...Perry Mason feels his lingustic abilities over-ride any of his outrageous and unqualified posts.

[Aces]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

He had so much fun last time, he wants to do it again.

 

I grade the book a 2.0 due to the strong odor of shiite. The odor results from the fact that the book has been owned by an arsehole for some time.

 

 

Hey! Where did the other shocked smiley go!?

[Mr. Zipper]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

He had so much fun last time, he wants to do it again.

 

I grade the book a 2.0 due to the strong odor of shiite. The odor results from the fact that the book has been owned by an arsehole for some time.

 

 

Sorry... I've been dying to use this smilie.

[Aces]

6.0

 

Higher if that stain back cover is some kind of stamp.

Lower if it's a water damage.

[divad]

Significant tanning . . .

[FFB]

What happened to being "proud of myself for not listening to 99% of the unobjective garbage spewed out" by the forum graders?

 

He had so much fun last time, he wants to do it again.

 

I grade the book a 2.0 due to the strong odor of shiite. The odor results from the fact that the book has been owned by an arsehole for some time.

 

Case in point...Perry Mason feels his lingustic abilities over-ride any of his outrageous and unqualified posts.

 

The fact that your buyer doesn't realize that color breaking spine stress takes a book out of 9.6 and 9.8 doesn't mean that you were right. Also, I didn't say your book wouldn't hit reserve. I said that *I* would not bid anymore to hit your reserve because I saw that you lied about the grade in your auction. Just to be clear.