Another stained comic! Grade this ASM 136 please~

[Aces]

Looks like this was one of greggy's reading copys.

 

 

The stain goes trough about halfway through the book, getting smaller each page.

[divad]

VG- 3.5 Tough stain

[Aces]

VG- 3.5 Tough stain

 

Darn that troll...

[october]

VG- 3.5 Tough stain

 

That bad? Looks like a solid 7.0 without the stain. I would be curious to see how other people react, tough to grade something like this. I would say 4.5 but

[drbanner]

VG- 3.5 Tough stain

 

That bad? Looks like a solid 7.0 without the stain. I would be curious to see how other people react, tough to grade something like this. I would say 4.5 but

 

The stain knocks it way down, but I don't think there are any guidelines in the grading guide for how much to deduct, and a concensus would be difficult to come to on this one since it affects just about the whole book.

 

I say 4.0...

[divad]

VG- 3.5 Tough stain

 

That bad? Looks like a solid 7.0 without the stain. I would be curious to see how other people react, tough to grade something like this. I would say 4.5 but

 

The stain knocks it way down, but I don't think there are any guidelines in the grading guide for how much to deduct, and a concensus would be difficult to come to on this one since it affects just about the whole book.

 

I say 4.0...

 

It just depends how "stain-friendly" you are!

 

Does a blood stain on a TOD bother you?