PGM MTU 53

[campcastellucio]

Learning the ropes on grading. Curious to see if mine will match up with yours.

Thanks in advance!

 

[Westy Steve]

Pretty book. I think the spine ticks hold it down. 9.0 on 7 out of 10 submittals and an 8.5 on 3 out of 10.

[divad]

Pretty book. I think the spine ticks hold it down. 9.0 on 7 out of 10 submittals and an 8.5 on 3 out of 10.

 

Nothing like committing . . .

[southerncross]

8.0 (thumbs u

[Conan_Aficionado]

8.5

[ROBTOTHEC]

8.5 IMHO

[divad]

8.0 (thumbs u

 

Just barely. Way too much going on (on the spine) to grade any higher.

[campcastellucio]

Thanks to all for your inputs.

[Conan_Aficionado]

I think every grading thread to end with the op's thoughts on what he thinks the book's grade is. That's how I end all my PGM threads with my own assessment of my book.

 

Just a thought, you don't have to give us your personal opinion, you did solicit us for our opinions and not vice versa.

[campcastellucio]

Conan - As stated above, I'm trying to build my grading skills by seeing where you long-timers go with your grades on the books I post. On this one, I am happy to say that I was thinking 8.5, so I seem to be in the ballpark. On other books that I or others have posted, I have been significantly off. I truly appreciate it when you take the time to comment on my postings. That being said, I am obviously not going to shoot myself in the foot by copping to a personal lower grade estimate. I'm the noob and I know it, but I will speak up if I strongly disagree with the gradings posted. This is a fantastic way to learn about the hobby and I am very happy to be here.