PGM: Shazam #28

[69CamaroZ28]

Just trying to brush up on my grading skills. I'm a little stuck on this one.

Book lays flat, small stain on right edge of front cover, white spine has ink transfer (?)

Front and back covers are brighter in hand. My scanner sucks.

Staples are tight, white (ish) pages, no hidden defects.

 

I was thinking somewhere between 5.0-6.0 because of the stain on the right edge

Thanks for any and all opinions

 

click on the image for larger scan

 

[uchiha101]

5.0 imo

 

[69CamaroZ28]

Any other opinions?

[Bomber-Bob]

I think it is much better than a 5.0, at least a 7.0 .

[69CamaroZ28]

I think it's a solid 7.0 but also thought it should be downgraded because of that stain. Just don't know how much to downgrade

[wongseefu]

about 6.5 on avg.

[Warren Oates]

6ish. large white spine is hiding one big tic? And yes small stain will hammer it.

 

 

[69CamaroZ28]

Thanks guys. I think calling it an overall 6.0 is a pretty safe bet

[wongseefu]

6.0 for me.