PGM Detective Comics 453

[barryallen-migration]

This one confuses me a bit. There's a hole in the last page before the back cover, and I'm not sure how much to deduct for it. I bought it on eBay a while back to fill a gap in my Detective collection and the seller listed it as VF. I didn't get a chance to read it till the other day, when I noticed the hole...I've never seen one like that before...not sure what caused it.

 

 

Click for high res

 

Click for high res

 

[barryallen-migration]

Bump

[Mijael.Levy]

If it is a VF , now with that big defect it falls to the Fine range , so i will say F/VF because it still looks better than a fine - , or a fine +

 

If you sell it just mention it

 

 

[barryallen-migration]

If it is a VF , now with that big defect it falls to the Fine range , so i will say F/VF because it still looks better than a fine - , or a fine +

 

If you sell it just mention it

 

 

Thanks! I wasn't sure if it would go above a F. I'm going to keep it as part of my collection for the time being, unless I get one in a nicer grade.

 

My time of buying stuff off of eBay is coming to an end, I think. I keep finding hidden defects, plus people love to overgrade.

[Mijael.Levy]

well that´s my opinion and i just have a listing at ebay with a similar problem :

 

An Avengers 6 that looks like a VF but has some little pinhole spine punctures , so i am grading it as a F/VF

 

Avenger 6

[barryallen-migration]

well that´s my opinion and i just have a listing at ebay with a similar problem :

 

An Avengers 6 that looks like a VF but has some little pinhole spine punctures , so i am grading it as a F/VF

 

Avenger 6

 

I have a similar problem with a nice Avengers 16 I just picked up. Otherwise it looks really good.