"Strict grader"?

[Rob]

This guy calls himself a strict grader. Check out the top left corner, and the crease along the top right corner. I hardly think this is VF.

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&category=35751&item=6510691712&rd=1

 

My favorite is this: "OTHERS MIGHT GRADE THIS BOOK HIGHER, BUT I WILL NOT."

[Aces]

Looks more like a 6.0 to me (using Silver-Age standards).

[SUPREMO]

not even close to an 8.0! Hah! My X-men 38 "beater" would also qualify as a VF according to that seller...

[divad]

This is not really the thread to talk about eBay listings - complain on the marketplace

 

Definitely not a VF, and perhaps not even a FN (ACES!) but still an issue I'll take in any grade.

 

He won't hit his reserve I'd give him $25 for the book though . . . in a NY minute!

[divad]

Looks more like a 6.0 to me (using Silver-Age standards).

 

No such thing . . .

[divad]

not even close to an 8.0! Hah! My X-men 38 "beater" would also qualify as a VF according to that seller...

 

X-Men #38 doesn't hold a candle to this book (beater or otherwise!)

 

even without the shocked Robin

[Rob]

This is not really the thread to talk about eBay listings - complain on the marketplace

 

You know, I thought about what thread to post it in, and decided it was more about grading than the marketplace. I think of that area for people buying or selling, and this listing is not mine. I just wanted an opinion on the grade. A double-check to see if I'm off the mark. Alas, I decided no one would really care, or at least take the time to mention it.