2015 CGC Green Eggs Grading Contest - FINAL RANKING

[rjpb]

World's Finest #88 is a Silver Age book. Just sayin'

[Scturo]

...AND we are DONE!

 

I did them because these ARE kind of interesting...

 

 

YOU are the BEST!

 

Yes, Shin and Andy,

[joe_collector]

World's Finest #88 is a Silver Age book. Just sayin'

 

Yeah, I know it is technically, but those 1957 books are kinda a grey zone for Marvel collectors. Plus, I thought it was 1955-56 when I made the cut.

 

And does it really matter?

[joe_collector]

...AND we are DONE!

 

I did them because these ARE kind of interesting...

 

 

YOU are the BEST!

 

Yes, Shin and Andy,

 

Agreed, and had I gotten involved earlier and realized what this actually was (the old Nik contest) I might have fought my way into the collection (we're in the midst of a home reno right now) and dredged out something for a prize.

 

Good work guys, and great work on the final video.

[sckao]

 

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

 

[kav]

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

This would be great because as soon as people get comfortable grading one age they get WHACKED with another and tumble in the ratings.

[thirdgreenham]

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

 

I don't do requests.

[01TheDude]

if ain't broke, don't try to fix it

[*Bronze age fan*]

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

 

I don't do requests.

 

 

 

I know that. How many time did I ask you for a MARVEL only contest??? I bordering on being a stalker!!!

[*Bronze age fan*]

if ain't broke, don't try to fix it

 

 

It IS broke. He should fix it! Marvel only next time. I wanna feel like Toro for once too!!!

[toro]

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

 

I don't do requests.

 

How about doing a theme? All DC War for Veterans Day, Romance for Valentine's day, Christmas/Thanksgiving/Halloween covers, Flag covers for Flag Day, tree covers for Arbor day.

[Gsims718]

Thanks for running this!

 

Always so much fun.

[1950's war comics]

I am having withdrawals already

 

it was so much fun and anticipation for 20 days in a row !!!!

[*Bronze age fan*]

So seeing these charts... Maybe ThirdGreenHam could consider maybe 4 books from each AGE to make a total of 20.

 

A Comic Book Grading Pentathlon

 

Books 1-4 Modern Age

Books 5-8 Copper Age

Books 9-12 Bronze Age

Books 13-16 Silver Age

Books 17-20 Golden Age

 

I don't do requests.

 

How about doing a theme? All DC War for Veterans Day, Romance for Valentine's day, Christmas/Thanksgiving/Halloween covers, Flag covers for Flag Day, tree covers for Arbor day.

 

 

 

Right. Guess you don't like seeing some people's names higher then yours!!!

[toro]

I am having withdrawals already

 

it was so much fun and anticipation for 20 days in a row !!!!

 

+1 I feel like I need to send in a grade.

[Comicdey]

Bronze Age champ.

 

 

Funny now I have a high grade Bronze Age OO collection I plan on premiering to the boards.

 

[kav]

FF 5.5

Dr Strange 8.5

 

uhhhh....

[rjpb]

FF 5.5

Dr Strange 8.5

 

uhhhh....

 

[kav]

[kav]

Next year can I enter all my grades after the contest is over?