YOU VERSUS CGC - Part I: Exciting Comics #57

[rjpb]

Without looking at any one else's guess or the actual grade I'm going to say 5.0.

 

Now to see how I did.

[makeminemego]

I would have guessed 5.0. If those creases weren't there, It'd get a friendly GA bump to 6.5-7.0, I'm guessing.

[vaillant]

I guess creases were too hard for my grade, but happy to see I am close.

Easier to grade GA than SA, more than often.

[1Cool]

I hate grading Golden Age books. I had it as a 5.0 but I always give Golden Age books a full grade bump after seeing the grades in the last grading contest.

[Shizzlemetimbers]

I would have gone 5.5