How about one Happy (Event) thread per poster per day?

[Bosco685]

Just start another thread. I'm sure it will go just fine.

 

Best idea yet.

 

That earns you a Happy Birthday!

 

No happy anniversary?

 

They took up a collection.

 

[bababooey]

OK this is my attempt to list all the options that have been suggested.

 

A Remains in CG w/individual threads

1 - Nightly BD threads created for every board member

2 - Nightly BD threads created for active members

3 - No nightly BD thread creation, let members who know the people create the threads if people get missed they can blame their friends because there's no one doing "the birthday thread job"

 

B Remains in CG single thread options

1- One single perpetual thread stickied

2- One single perpetual thread not stickied

3 - Daily thread created for all people celebrating birthdays

 

C New sub-forum

1 - BD threads and other community events celebrated

2 - BD threads and selected active CG/community threads moved to new sub-forum

 

If we were in an A 2 situation, nightly threads for active board members - my preferred solutions in order are A3, B1, B2/B3, A2, C1, C2, A1

 

[drbanner]

OK this is my attempt to list all the options that have been suggested.

 

A Remains in CG w/individual threads

1 - Nightly BD threads created for every board member

2 - Nightly BD threads created for active members

3 - No nightly BD thread creation, let members who know the people create the threads if people get missed they can blame their friends because there's no one doing "the birthday thread job"

 

B Remains in CG single thread options

1- One single perpetual thread stickied

2- One single perpetual thread not stickied

3 - Daily thread created for all people celebrating birthdays

 

C New sub-forum

1 - BD threads and other community events celebrated

2 - BD threads and selected active CG/community threads moved to new sub-forum

 

If we were in an A 2 situation, nightly threads for active board members - my preferred solutions in order are A3, B1, B2/B3, A2, C1, C2, A1

 

Looks like we need another poll!

[RockMyAmadeus]

As it stands now, before the locked thread scrolls off the front page and into oblivion, the vote is 37 (74%) to 13 (26%) in favor of the "Personal" sub-forum.

 

Still pretty clear where the people are wanting to go.

[Domo Arigato]

[CAHokie]

 

Maybe next time you will use your powers for good and not evil!

[bababooey]

 

Actually the way that poll was worded the choices I laid out are much more clearly stated.

 

I think the majority want change but when the first option says "yes, new subforum" - you snap of all of the "imsickofthis " votes....

And then anyone interested enough to read further sees option two as

"no, leave things the way they are (which is totally broken) followed by....and find another solution"

 

[Domo Arigato]

 

Maybe next time you will use your powers for good and not evil!

If you want to build a proper mess house...sometimes you have to squash a few flies?

[Domo Arigato]

 

Actually the way that poll was worded the choices I laid out are much more clearly stated.

 

I think the majority want change but when the first option says "yes, new subforum" - you snap of all the "imsickofthis" votes....

And then anyone interested enough to read further sees option two as

"no, leave things the way they are (which is totally broken) followed by....and find another solution"

Yeah....that must be it.

[bababooey]

 

Actually the way that poll was worded the choices I laid out are much more clearly stated.

 

I think the majority want change but when the first option says "yes, new subforum" - you snap of all the "imsickofthis" votes....

And then anyone interested enough to read further sees option two as

"no, leave things the way they are (which is totally broken) followed by....and find another solution"

Yeah....that must be it.

I agree a new subforum is preferable to having to wade through 4/5 new threads a day with the same 10 posts in each thread. Anything is better than that, I mean this...

 

 

 

[Domo Arigato]

I agree a new subforum is preferable to having to wade through 4/5 new threads a day with the same 10 posts in each thread. Anything is better than that, I mean this...

Absolutely. (thumbs u

 

I don't think we'll find a perfect solution to make everyone happy....just looking for a compromise that everyone can be "ok" with.