no pics just a question

[anstettoman]

on a book that would grade out at fine- that has a 3 hole punch that is thru the book how many grading points would this reduce the grade (book in question is a asm #11. thanks

[mattn792]

I don't recall ever seeing a three hole punched book graded, but my fear would be it could end up somewhere between 1.5 and 2.5 since there's a small, but significant portion of the book completely missing.

[Topnotchman]

Depends on if the holes are in the margin or they are in the balloons and art, disrupting the story. Could be as low as 0.5.

[Johnny545]

It's possible they grade it qualified, but otherwise ignore the hole punch - see the detective comics 85 on eBay.

 

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Detective-Comics-91-Cgc-8-0-Qualified-Ow-White-Pages-Joker-Cover-And-Story-/231841057515?

[anstettoman]

thanks for the info appreciate it

[jeranimal]

You should try posting this question in the Ask CGC section to see what they say.

 

Good luck!

[Readymade Breakup]

There was a Sensation 1 that was recently for sale on ebay that got a 3.0 blue. You can search and also find the same book in a thread here as well. In gold I think...Good luck!