Help! Miscut or trimmed?

[jeranimal]

Hi guys!

 

I purchased this recently but I'm concerned that it may be trimmed on the right edge. I'd like to know what others think and any suggestions on how to confirm or deny the trimming.

 

I'm hoping it is just a miscut but I don't want to send to CGC and have it come back with a PLOD.

 

Thanks in advance!

 

[D84]

Take a picture of the side. If the right edge is whiter than the top and bottom, it could be trimmed.

[jeranimal]

Take a picture of the side. If the right edge is whiter than the top and bottom, it could be trimmed.

 

Right edge looks to be the same color. What do you think? Seller has had it for 5 years but doesn't know the history before that.

[drotto]

It might be trimmed. With comics all the pages are cut to the same size. This results in the centerfold generally sticking out a little further then the rest of the pages. If the right side is 100% straight (meaning you do not have a slight peaking effect) it could be trimmed.

[oakman29]

It looks fine to me, but it's hard to tell 100% by a picture.

[rodan57]

It looks fine to me, but it's hard to tell 100% by a picture.

 

Same here. Just looks like a small miscut with the bottom a bit narrower than the top. Not an uncommon quality control issue and nothing that would affect a CGC grade -- though a raw buyer might be more circumspect.

[silverseeker]

It looks fine to me, but it's hard to tell 100% by a picture.

 

Same here. Just looks like a small miscut with the bottom a bit narrower than the top. Not an uncommon quality control issue and nothing that would affect a CGC grade -- though a raw buyer might be more circumspect.

I agree...from the photos it looks like just a miscut.

[PovertyRow]

It looks fine to me, but it's hard to tell 100% by a picture.

 

Same here. Just looks like a small miscut with the bottom a bit narrower than the top. Not an uncommon quality control issue and nothing that would affect a CGC grade -- though a raw buyer might be more circumspect.

I agree...from the photos it looks like just a miscut.

 

Same here!