Who's The Most Overrated - Ties 13-16 + 3

[king_felix-migration]

As ever, newbies look here.

 

I'll re-run Ditko/Cassady who drew last time and in the unlikely event of another draw, put them in a 3-way play-off against Kevin Smith next time.

[Norrin_Radd]

R1 - Tie 15

You may choose only one

Todd McFarlane

Rob Liefield

 

 

 

 

Must.... choose.... lesser.... of.... two.... evils!

 

 

 

P.S. - I got my internet access back (sort of).

[delekkerste]

R1 - Tie 15

You may choose only one

Todd McFarlane

Rob Liefield

 

How can Liefeld be "overrated" when he is jeered, panned and roundly criticized by 99% of the people on this Board?? McFarlane got my vote because a lot of people seem to think that his horrificly bad artwork (only slightly better than Liefeld's, IMO) is actually good.

[king_felix-migration]

Kirby pipped, Morrison by a mile, McFarlane/Liefield tie , SR puts JR in his place and Ditko wins his rematch comfortably.

[Norrin_Radd]

Kirby pipped, Morrison by a mile, McFarlane/Liefield tie , SR puts JR in his place and Ditko wins his rematch comfortably.

 

I say that since McFarlane and Liefield tied, they both lost and get tossed out.

 

Either that or a special runoff with Robert Prechter.