Justice League of America #1 1960

[alexmtl]

Apologies for missing back cover but seller does not provide it. Just want to get a rough idea based on the cover.

 

Seller grades it VG and just wondering if that makes sense. Seems to me the missing piece on top right is a pretty significant defect no?

 

[comicjack]

Without the back cover tough to give it a grade.The small corner piece would still fall in the vg zone but I see a 3.5 to 4.0 without the back showing

Welcome to the boards!

[FineCollector]

I used to feel the same as the OP. Pieces missing were treated much more harshly by Overstreet than CGC. People are perfectly willing to accept chipping on mid-grade books now, so the corner missing, although distracting, isn't disastrous. If you need to recalibrate, go look at the shredded cole slaw people are calling G nowadays, and come back to this one.

 

I agree that it's in the realm of VG, but not a very nice example of it, so 3.5.

[oakman29]

I used to feel the same as the OP. Pieces missing were treated much more harshly by Overstreet than CGC. People are perfectly willing to accept chipping on mid-grade books now, so the corner missing, although distracting, isn't disastrous. If you need to recalibrate, go look at the shredded cole slaw people are calling G nowadays, and come back to this one.

 

I agree that it's in the realm of VG, but not a very nice example of it, so 3.5.

Agreed, certainly a VG. 3.5\4.0

[HighStakesComics]

4.0

[Point Five]

I'd guess 3.5; nice for grade but a near miss of VG IMO with a good amount of general edge wear. Could of course be lower depending on back cover.

 

 

[SkOw]

Without seeing the back cover, I can't go any higher than 3.0. Depending on the back cover I could go to 3.5.