Please grade this golden age Eerie #15!

[Point Five]

An Ebay gamble that looks and feels amazing in hand... very pretty front cover, absolutely dripping with gloss. Tiny spine split at top, light stains top of back cover.

 

Thoughts and grades welcome. Thanks all!

 

 

 

 

[Ron Rau]

My thoughts are....I love it!

[comicjack]

It gets the gold bump so i'm looking at 6.5/7.0 nice pickup for ebay

[KryptoMayor]

I agree, this is an amazing book. I fear the grade may come in a bit lower than it deserves. I'm thinking 6.5-7.0 because of the slight water stain on the top edge of the back cover (looks like front, left corner too unless it's foxing/dust shadows) and many of us knows how CGC feels about water stains.

 

The impact dings (top spine split) on both spine corners will also be a factor, but doesn't take away from the beauty of this book (just the grade). Otherwise I think this book presents like an 8.5.

[sacentaur]

Very nice book - overall a technical 6.5 (but presents better).

[AJD]

I'm higher than the previous graders here. Can't see why this couldn't get a 7.5

 

Great pickup!

[fiendish]

/agree with 6.5

 

Awesome book!

[piper]

6.5

[DR.X]

6.5 for me too. what an amazing looking copy and the color is fantastic.