PGM: Vault of Horror #17

[EC ed]

Hi gang,

 

Tricky grading issue here, thanks to an interior page defect....

 

Specifically, this book has a 1" triangle missing from the corner of the 6th interior page, which does not affect the art panel. The Overstreet Grading Guide provides guidelines about missing corners from the COVER, but makes no mention of guidelines for missing interior corner pieces.

 

Thanks in advance for your thoughts...

 

(FYI - I posted a more general question about a missing interior page piece in a thread over in the grading/resto forum - LINK )

 

Ed

 

 

 

My grading notes: general wear; diag. creases urfc; 1" lower right corner triangle missing from 6th interior page - doesn't affect art panel; pencil writing under the moon on the fc

 

Scans:

 

 

 

[Mio]

VG

[divad]

4.5, and I don't think the torn interior page corner has an impact at this grade.

[EC ed]

Thanks for your thoughts, guys. That's pretty much what I was thinking, as well. Just wanted to make sure I wasn't missing the boat with that interior page situation.

[fiendish]

4.0-4.5