2016 Green Eggs Grading Contest- Round 7

[MustEatBrains]

 

Oooooooh so close to double bullseyes!

 

 

Me too. 4.0 and 9.0

 

I'm ecstatic though.

[grebal]

 

Oooooooh so close to double bullseyes!

 

 

Me too. 4.0 and 9.0

 

I'm ecstatic though.

 

Exact same picks.

 

Considered both the actual grades, but moved on each and missed both.

 

: (

[porcupine48]

Crud - thought I had this round. 4 points will have to do.

ditto

[1Cool]

I guess the bottom right corner of the one book was caused by shaking the book in the slab.

[jcjames]

 

Oooooooh so close to double bullseyes!

 

 

Me too. 4.0 and 9.0

 

I'm ecstatic though.

Same grades as me.

 

I'm still working on honing that "CGC-bump".

 

[grebal]

I guess the bottom right corner of the one book was caused by shaking the book in the slab.

 

Could help explain the 9.2.

 

Anyone else think there was surface wear bottom of spine on that book also?

[1950's war comics]

BINGO!! (not)

[trmoore54]

Ah shoot...switched my 9.2 grade to 9.0 ( thought it really could be an 8.5)...the other one . went with 4.5...that book was an official MF

Take my 4 points and run...

[Comicdey]

9.2

 

Missed it by a mile as 8.0

 

 

CGC has not been so nice to me

 

3.5. Yep.

[grebal]

Totally looked 3.5. Thought maybe they picked some books that were not quite what they appeared to be at first blush.

 

I've seen 4.0 with the same stain (I thought) if they looked very nice otherwise.

There's a ST 110 on sale in the GA/SA/BA Sale forum with the same-ish stain at 4.0. So I went high (broke my streak of never overgrading).

[thirdgreenham]

[*Bronze age fan*]

Wow. I had a good round??? 8 points??? Almost doubled my totals! .

[thunsicker]

I was at 3.0 and 8.0. I guess the lower right corner must be SCS and the scuffing must be on the case.

[Noodlez]

I'll take my double bullseye and run!

[thirdgreenham]

Wow. I had a good round??? 8 points??? Almost doubled my totals! .

 

there were quite a few good rounds....let's see if anything changes near the top of the leaderboard....

[Couchy81]

Ah shoot...switched my 9.2 grade to 9.0 ( thought it really could be an 8.5)...the other one . went with 4.5...that book was an official MF

Take my 4 points and run...

 

I thought it was 8.5 as well but dropped down to 8.0 because ive been over shooting. of course this book....

[toro]

Wow, I hammered that top and bottom spine and the right corner on that Unexpected. Got another "unexpected" -1

[grebal]

I'm falling.

 

But I enjoyed my brief time in the clouds. !

 

[thirdgreenham]

Wow, I hammered that top and bottom spine and the right corner on that Unexpected. Got another "unexpected" -1

 

Ooh boy!

[thirdgreenham]

I'm falling.

 

But I enjoyed my brief time in the clouds. !

 

Just take another red pill.