de-slabbed Fantastic Four 59

[grebal]

Recently removed this comic from CGC case - see label.

 

Open spoiler to see the grade it got, listing this for those who like to practice.

 

 

Got a 8.0, don't know if any grading notes, imo it might have gotten an 8.5 except maybe the back isn't fresh enough, but am happy with it in my raw collection as it is.

 

 

 

And by the way, to CGC quality control, there was no micro fiber paper in the comic. ! Youz guys owe me a coupla pages.

 

 

[comicquant]

I picked it! The culprit is the upper-left hand corner. If that crease wasn't there I would say higher. There are other minor issues that solidify the grade but the crease is what first caught my attention. Thanks for doing this; knowing the results immediately is nice!

[Comicdey]

I was going to guess 8.5 so 8.0 seems about right

[gradejunky]

I was sitting at 8.0/8.5 myself...I stillz got it!

 

When is the next grading challenge?? Is that still going on?

[Squad008]

I guessed a 7.5, hopefully that means I under-grade all my books one grade

 

Awesome thread, thanks for posting!

[NoMan]

7.5. I didn't peek at grade. See damaged Upper left corner.

[NoMan]

I was close. I think I gotta ease up on my grading. Tend to grade too low

[rjpb]

I thought it was a solid 8.0, with a shot at 8.5