Question about potentiAL trade 0

[bradc72175]

Would it be insane to trade an ironfist 1 cgc 9.8 (1970's), for a Captain marvel 14 cgc 9.8 1:30 signed by conner and Stan lee? Thoughts and advice are appreciated.

[SquareChaos]

Assuming you mean the 1975 Claremont / Byrne #1.

I would guess it depends on what your reason for even considering it is. I had to do some online searching to see what the 1:30 even was, I wasn't familiar with that cover. Anyway, if the plan is to keep whichever book you end up with... I personally wouldn't make the trade, but that is just me. If the plan is to sell the book you end up with, I'd do more research and see which one I thought I could get more for 

[Stat Monsters]

I'd keep the Iron Fist, it's vintage and rare to find in 9.8 condition vs scooping up a potentially flash-in-the-pan modern book, which 9.8's are a dime a dozen these days and a Stan Lee autograph on a comic he has nothing to do with has not only less appeal, but irrelevant appeal and sort of like getting Joe Montana to autograph a Hockey Puck.