Please grade this book

[newbywancanewby-migration]

[arexcrooke]

Nice book. A few questions though. On the bottom edge, is that a crease? Also, is that color loss on the right edge about 3/4 or the way down?

Suggesstion, re-scan and save at a higher dpi, like 250-300. That will take the pixelation out and allow us to see the book better.

[divad]

[Stronguy]

Looks better than mine...

 

Just based on those scans I'd say 5.0 - 5.5

[uclapeterg]

Probably 5.5.

[newbywancanewby-migration]

What looks like a crease along the bottom is an extension of the crack and not a crease. What may look like a color loss up the right edge is Marvel chipping, I think.

[newbywancanewby-migration]

I did scan those at 300 dpi. I sent them through photo bucket this time because the previous scans didn't look as good as these do.

[nik]

Beautiful book, VG/FN would be my guess.

[KingOfRulers]

I'd say 5.5 to 6.0 would be good. Very nice book. Ah, but a whimsical dream for me.

[Aces]

 

6.5!!!

 

Get that puppy slabbed express before these low-ball grades start drawing the sharks to your PM box!

 

[Aces]

I did scan those at 300 dpi. I sent them through photo bucket this time because the previous scans didn't look as good as these do.

 

PM!

[uclapeterg]

 

6.5!!!

 

Get that puppy slabbed express before these low-ball grades start drawing the sharks to your PM box!

 

 

Hey, don't talk about me that way!

 

He ignored my PM

[Aces]

He is slow to respond on PMs.

He just got back to mine from over a week ago.

 

I'm still waiting for his reply about sending me the 300dpi scans.

[newbywancanewby-migration]

This one came back a 5.0.

[nik]

[Aces]

That's one of the nicest 5.0 I've ever seen.

Are there non-color breaking creases that lower the grade cause it sure looks Fine from this end?