grade for x-men 1 please

[newbywancanewby-migration]

[ComicSupply]

VG-

 

If it wasn't for those pieces missing that would be a very clean copy.

[casey1870]

I'll agree with 3.5 on this one. Tears on the fc lower it considerably.......... Maybe even lower than that

[Aces]

4.0/4.5

 

CGC doesn't beat up chipping too much.

[Aces]

I'll agree with 3.5 on this one. Tears on the fc lower it considerably.......... Maybe even lower than that

 

You mean the marvel chipping along the right side?

[divad]

You should have this one slabbed - I think you will be pleasantly surprised

[jimm94]

5.0, maybe 5.5 even with the Marvel chipping. Great copy!

[divad]

5.0, maybe 5.5 even with the Marvel chipping. Great copy!

ditto

[inconceivable]

You should have this one slabbed - I think you will be pleasantly surprised

 

I would go as far as to say this book could get a 6.0

 

Please get it graded.

 

Dan

[october]

Real shame about the chipping, that copy looks to have great cover whites, gloss and color. I would go 5.0 myself, but a book like that is tricky to grade.

 

[uclapeterg]

You should have this one slabbed - I think you will be pleasantly surprised

 

I agree. I got a 3.5 with chipping worse than this (but in a smaller area) and various other problems (like heavy corner creasing).

 

I can see anywhere from 4.0 to 5.0.

[whetteon]

I went with 5.0 but I was off a grade in the grading contest so adjust for a grade and you get 4.5! ha!

[casey1870]

I'll agree with 3.5 on this one. Tears on the fc lower it considerably.......... Maybe even lower than that

 

You mean the marvel chipping along the right side?

 

Hell I did'nt know that was marvel chipping .....Looks like something that got stuck in the printing press & was pulled out! Sorry for my newbeeness...hail to you all.....

[newbywancanewby-migration]

This book was mailed today for grading. Will reveal grade when and if...

[ComicSupply]

Boo, I suck.

[Aces]

This book was mailed today for grading. Will reveal grade when and if...

 

Since we are getting an excact grade soon.

 

4.5

Hope ya do a little better but that chipping is rather strong.

[Comcasthawk]

VG-

 

If it wasn't for those pieces missing that would be a very clean copy.

 

 

Hey Russ, u should be that "tough" on your own books at Comicsupply.com......

[KingOfRulers]

Nice book! The book has great eye appeal for a lower grade copy! Too bad mine doesn't look that nice.

 

I'd say it's a 3.5.

[newbywancanewby-migration]

Man, you guys are good! This came back a 4.5. Aces was right on. Offers?

[Aces]

Man, you guys are good! This came back a 4.5. Aces was right on. Offers?

 

I vote newbywancanewby runs the next contest!