GPA subscribers - how should we record this sale?

[gpanalysis]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

[supapimp]

contact the seller and ask if payment has been sent. did you enter my sale of batman 251 CGC 9.2 sig series sale of $251 to GPA?

[divad]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

 

Yeah, e-mail "Carlos" and ask him if he received the money. If he did, "book him, Dan-O"

 

(too many cliches?)

 

Oh, and make sure you scratch the prior sale.

[gpanalysis]

 

Oh, and make sure you scratch the prior sale.

 

The previous sale is already noted as a non-paying bidder result.

[jbud73]

If it wasn't for the 3/4 inch spine splits at the top and bottom, this book would be FN+ or better

 

Thats my favorite line from the Auction - no and if it wasnt for alot of other defects all my books would be NM+ or better. Actually it was very upfront of the seller to disclose that - though any serious bidder would have called for the note anyway, or at least you hope so.

 

There is no way this sale should be included in GPA unless it can be a confirmed transaction.

[gpanalysis]

contact the seller and ask if payment has been sent. did you enter my sale of batman 251 CGC 9.2 sig series sale of $251 to GPA?

 

Do you mean a private sale? We only accept private sale info from a certain number of dealers, so we wouldn't be able to include your sale

[gpanalysis]

Yeah, e-mail "Carlos" and ask him if he received the money. If he did, "book him, Dan-O"

 

Are you able to PM me his email address? Or you can contact him on our behalf it that's not an option.

[Silver Surfer]

Well there appears to be numerous other bidders just below the winner so perhaps this is okay?

[divad]

Yeah, e-mail "Carlos" and ask him if he received the money. If he did, "book him, Dan-O"

 

Are you able to PM me his email address? Or you can contact him on our behalf it that's not an option.

 

I sent him an e-mail. I will report back, mon capitan!

[FFB]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

 

Looks like a legitimate seller and a low feedback bidder. Everyone was a low feedback bidder once. This guy has been bidding (unsuccessfully) on a number of books over the last month or so, all from different sellers. This is the only one he has won.

 

Unless there is some reason other than the bidder's low feedback why this looks fishy, I'd record it like any other sale.

[Ares]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

 

Looks like a legitimate seller and a low feedback bidder. Everyone was a low feedback bidder once. This guy has been bidding (unsuccessfully) on a number of books over the last month or so, all from different sellers. This is the only one he has won.

 

Unless there is some reason other than the bidder's low feedback why this looks fishy, I'd record it like any other sale.

What he said...

[supapimp]

contact the seller and ask if payment has been sent. did you enter my sale of batman 251 CGC 9.2 sig series sale of $251 to GPA?

 

Do you mean a private sale? We only accept private sale info from a certain number of dealers, so we wouldn't be able to include your sale

 

it was sold on here in the CGC marketplace.

[gpanalysis]

Yeah, e-mail "Carlos" and ask him if he received the money. If he did, "book him, Dan-O"

 

Are you able to PM me his email address? Or you can contact him on our behalf it that's not an option.

 

I sent him an e-mail. I will report back, mon capitan!

 

Thanks! Please post here or email info@gpanalysis.com when you have an answer

[esquirecomics]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

 

Looks like a legitimate seller and a low feedback bidder. Everyone was a low feedback bidder once. This guy has been bidding (unsuccessfully) on a number of books over the last month or so, all from different sellers. This is the only one he has won.

 

Unless there is some reason other than the bidder's low feedback why this looks fishy, I'd record it like any other sale.

 

I agree. The buyer who bought my Superman #2 CGC 8.0 for $15,500 had a feedback of one (and, of course, he was the only bidder), and the sale was completely legit.

[gpanalysis]

How do you guys feel the following result should be recorded in GPA:

 

http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=6532942757

 

We normally use "Questionable bidding history" when an item is won on a single bid, by a low-rated bidder and where no other comics have been purchased by them in the past (the only other item recorded in their feedback is a non-comic item).

 

Any thoughts?

 

Looks like a legitimate seller and a low feedback bidder. Everyone was a low feedback bidder once. This guy has been bidding (unsuccessfully) on a number of books over the last month or so, all from different sellers. This is the only one he has won.

 

Unless there is some reason other than the bidder's low feedback why this looks fishy, I'd record it like any other sale.

 

I agree. The buyer who bought my Superman #2 CGC 8.0 for $15,500 had a feedback of one (and, of course, he was the only bidder), and the sale was completely legit.

 

True Mark - and that's why we're asking for a followup - at the time you kept us abreast of the situation and verified the sale. Let's hope we can do the same for this. At the end of the day the sale will be reported, we just need to make sure we note any subsequent non-sale.

[ComicSupply]

Hey GPA,

 

I was going to ask if you wanted me to give you our sales results. We just started carrying CGC books, but I am sure that in 6 months to a year we will be selling many more. Can give you the info if you want.

[gpanalysis]

Hey GPA,

 

I was going to ask if you wanted me to give you our sales results. We just started carrying CGC books, but I am sure that in 6 months to a year we will be selling many more. Can give you the info if you want.

 

You can email George at george.pantela@gpanalysis.com - he'll give you a call to discuss.

[ComicSupply]

[divad]