ComicSupply Grading Contest Round 5

[deathlok]

Bella, sorry to bring this up but #43 Slacker is a problem.

 

Round #1 Slacker loses to #44 Flying Donut

Round #2 Slacker (still in winners group) loses to #44 Flying Donut

Round #3 Slacker (in losers group) beats #46 The_Beyonder

Round #4 Slacker (in losers group) beats #41 rjpb

 

 

So Slacker should have dropped to Losers group for Round 2.

Slacker should then have dropped to Mega-Losers group for Round 3.

 

If I am wrong, please someone let me know.

 

I can't help because I only face guys with names starting in "A" or numbers so I don't pay attention to the "S"s.

 

I just checked.

Team America was 44 and dropped out so 43: Slaker got a free bye.

That's what I thought, except Comics Supply told Flying Donut that he was going to replace Team America prior to the deadline. CS then told FD that he needed to submit a grade for Round 1.

 

So then CS posted the grades after all grades were submitted as follows:

 

#43 Losers Bracket

#44 Stays in Winners

 

So it appears as if Slacker did not get a bye for Round 1, but was beaten by FD.

[Aces]

Bella, sorry to bring this up but #43 Slacker is a problem.

 

Round #1 Slacker loses to #44 Flying Donut

Round #2 Slacker (still in winners group) loses to #44 Flying Donut

Round #3 Slacker (in losers group) beats #46 The_Beyonder

Round #4 Slacker (in losers group) beats #41 rjpb

 

 

So Slacker should have dropped to Losers group for Round 2.

Slacker should then have dropped to Mega-Losers group for Round 3.

 

If I am wrong, please someone let me know.

 

I can't help because I only face guys with names starting in "A" or numbers so I don't pay attention to the "S"s.

 

I just checked.

Team America was 44 and dropped out so 43: Slaker got a free bye.

That's what I thought, except Comics Supply told Flying Donut that he was going to replace Team America prior to the deadline. CS then told FD that he needed to submit a grade for Round 1.

 

So then CS posted the grades after all grades were submitted as follows:

 

#43 Losers Bracket

#44 Stays in Winners

 

So it appears as if Slacker did not get a bye for Round 1, but was beaten by FD.

 

Oh boy...

[october]

Jeeze, like October_Fire really needs a Bye ... it should automatically go to a more deserving person, like ME!!

 

[kiltman]

inconceivable vs kiltman

 

We meet again.

[Lazyboy]

Posted by ComicSupply in GC Round 1 Thread (in response to FD's request to join):

 

"Oh fine, your player number

 

(00-)Double O Negative.

 

Just Kidding, your player #44. Since your new, a grade is needed. The player you are facing off against still gets to move on, but you might be knocked down. So choose wisely "

[kiltman]

Posted by ComicSupply in GC Round 1 Thread (in response to FD's request to join):

 

"Oh fine, your player number

 

(00-)Double O Negative.

 

Just Kidding, your player #44. Since your new, a grade is needed. The player you are facing off against still gets to move on, but you might be knocked down. So choose wisely "

I vaguely remembered him saying some like that but didn't want to say anything thinking i was probably wrong. Nice work

[Red Hook]

Jeeze, like October_Fire really needs a Bye ... it should automatically go to a more deserving person, like ME!!

 

 

JC....I get the feeling that if you happen to win this thing.......

 

WE'RE NEVER GOING TO HEAR THE END OF IT!

 

Tell me I'm wrong.....please?

[joe_collector]

JC....I get the feeling that if you happen to win this thing.......

 

WE'RE NEVER GOING TO HEAR THE END OF IT!

 

Nah, as I know these contests are for fun and are worth about 2 dead flies.

 

Then again, I am glad I'm whopping [embarrasing lack of self control] at 4-0, rather than squeaking by with a ton of (suspicious?) ties.

[inconceivable]

inconceivable vs kiltman

 

We meet again.

 

So we do. Nice to play against you again. Good luck!

 

Dan

[Red Hook]

JC....I get the feeling that if you happen to win this thing.......

 

WE'RE NEVER GOING TO HEAR THE END OF IT!

 

Nah, as I know these contests are for fun and are worth about 2 dead flies.

 

Then again, I am glad I'm whopping [embarrasing lack of self control] at 4-0, rather than squeaking by with a ton of (suspicious?) ties.

 

Now, wait a minute......I thought it was my role to start talk of any and all conspiracies on the boards!!??!!!

[deathlok]

Posted by ComicSupply in GC Round 1 Thread (in response to FD's request to join):

 

"Oh fine, your player number

 

(00-)Double O Negative.

 

Just Kidding, your player #44. Since your new, a grade is needed. The player you are facing off against still gets to move on, but you might be knocked down. So choose wisely "

 

 

So even though FD had to submit a grade,

 

If he beat Slacker, both Slacker and FD move forward?

If he lost to Slacker, Slacker would move forward and FD would drop to Losers?

 

So either way, Slacker advances win or lose for Round 1?

 

Is that right?

[Aces]

Posted by ComicSupply in GC Round 1 Thread (in response to FD's request to join):

 

"Oh fine, your player number

 

(00-)Double O Negative.

 

Just Kidding, your player #44. Since your new, a grade is needed. The player you are facing off against still gets to move on, but you might be knocked down. So choose wisely "

 

 

So even though FD had to submit a grade,

 

If he beat Slacker, both Slacker and FD move forward?

If he lost to Slacker, Slacker would move forward and FD would drop to Losers?

 

So either way, Slacker advances win or lose for Round 1?

 

Is that right?

 

Yep.

He was promised a bye so he got one I guess.

[joe_collector]

This contest has more bye's than a transsexual orgy.

[Darthdiesel]

This contest has more bye's than a transsexual orgy.

 

I guess we are talking about the contestants...

[Aces]

This contest has more bye's than a transsexual orgy.

 

*Insert standard "You'll have to ask greggy about that." comment here*

[kiltman]

inconceivable vs kiltman

 

We meet again.

 

So we do. Nice to play against you again. Good luck!

 

Dan

Good luck to you too

[FlyingDonut]

Posted by ComicSupply in GC Round 1 Thread (in response to FD's request to join):

 

"Oh fine, your player number

 

(00-)Double O Negative.

 

Just Kidding, your player #44. Since your new, a grade is needed. The player you are facing off against still gets to move on, but you might be knocked down. So choose wisely "

 

 

So even though FD had to submit a grade,

 

If he beat Slacker, both Slacker and FD move forward?

If he lost to Slacker, Slacker would move forward and FD would drop to Losers?

 

So either way, Slacker advances win or lose for Round 1?

 

Is that right?

 

Yep.

He was promised a bye so he got one I guess.

 

I think that's what happened, but I did submit a grade for Round 1.

[ComicSupply]

Yes,

 

He got the bye because I felt that it was fair to let him keep the bye because I didn't know if he would get the PM or know that he was now going up against someone.

[mica]

#30 vs #31

 

Mica vs Nefaria. My two former competitors fighting it out.

 

Thanks Norinn for clueing me in on who in the world 31 is.

[october]

 

 

rather than squeaking by with a ton of (suspicious?) ties.

 

I proved myself last contest. I don't cheat and I didn't make the rules for the contest. Juststopit.DoyouWANTastrike? off.