Rip Hunter #1 (2 copies) 0

[evilskip]

Just for a brain twister, here are two copies of Rip Hunter #1. One has been slabbed and the other hasn't. One is graded by CGC, the other isn't, but it does have a grade by a company.

The first two pics are the slabbed book, pages off white to white. Back cover included.

The second two are the unslabbed book. Pages are are an OWL 7.5 to 8. Only damage is what you can see.

Guess the grades. Good luck. I'll post the grades in a couple of days.

[davet75]

5.0 slabbed

4.5 unslabbed

[FoggyNelson]

7.0 slab 6.5 unslab🙏🏼🙏🏼⁉️

[evilskip]

The slabbed Rip Hunter #1 clocked in as a 6.0 CGC.

The unslabbed Rip Hunter was graded as a 3.5 by MCS.

[1950's war comics]

the 3.5 looks better ...

[evilskip]

1 hour ago, 1950's war comics said:

the 3.5 looks better ...

That is what I think too. I was tempted to by the slabbed book but after looking at mine, decided to pass.

[romanheart]

6.0, 3.5