RANKING THE SILVER AGE PEDIGREES

[doc_sampson-migration]

i know this is a topic which has been somewhat debated here but lets put it to the poll!

 

curator

 

western penn

 

bethlehem

 

pacific coast

 

golden state

 

bowling green

 

green river

 

ohio

 

boston

 

mass.

 

marnin rosenbergs "A" pedigree

 

[doc_sampson-migration]

i screwed up the poll option,can someone fix it please??!!

[comicmankev]

And don't forget the Winnipeg to go at the bottom!

[doc_sampson-migration]

hey

 

the winnipegs may not be as cgc high numerically ie structure as some of the other pedigrees but they have killer state of preservation/page whiteness

[comicmankev]

Hey, I own more Winnipegs than any other, but everyone puts them down because of the writting on the covers, so I just joined in! I personally think it gives them more history

[doc_sampson-migration]

totally agree on the pen writing-gives the book provenance and really is not obtrusive, name is neatly and discreetly written unlike the big fat ugly grease pencil arrival dates of the ohio books

[fantastic_four]

Only you can fix the poll--go back and edit your message.

[murph0]

I'd rank like this..

Western PA

Pacific Coast

Mass

White Mountain

Boston

Northland

Green River

Ohio (does this collection even have any NM books?)

*Bethlehem (never actually seen one in person, can't rate it)

*Bowling Green (again, never seen one)

*A (read above)

 

Obviously there may be a difference of opinion in quality but of the Marvel books that I've bought from these this is how I'd rank it

 

Brian

 

[notch_top]

Don't forget the Curator Murph....

 

 

[Mister_Comics]

All Pedigree's are pretty RANK. Did ya ever smell one?

[supapimp]

you guys either suck or are lazy

 

 

[supapimp]

awwwwright! whose the wise guy that picked the sticko'butter pedigree?

[drbanner]

Wait a sec...by "sticko'butter pedigree" are you referring to the "Devil's Lake Collection"? You know, the one that led to the Moldy Butter Conspiracy and subsequent (alleged) cover up, or something different? It's been a while since we had a good one - I think we need more, better butter collection discovery stories!!

[supapimp]

hey i like vincent over at metropolis so i don't want him to take it personally...so shhhh besides, i know who picked the sticko'butter pedigree, it isn't that hard to figure out.

[murph0]

Oops I took that one out accidentally but I'd probably rank it around 5th or 6th, mostly due to the fact that all the nice books from the collection aren't available so you really only see the so-so ones.

 

Brian

[supapimp]

oops, i left out circle 8 pedigree

[blowout]

You left out White Mountain too.

[murph0]

FYI Golden State isn't recognized as a pedigree although those books are very nice. Kinda the same deal as the Slobodian collection..

 

Brian