PGM Superman 2 2

[SellinMyCollection]

Ok, grading these are... um difficult.  I have Adventure of Superman 500 and Superman 75 in poly bags.  I am not removing them so how are they graded?  Bagged and boarded since purchase.  Let me know your comments and feedback. I have no idea how to grade these except 9.8 but am I even close?
Thanks for looking

[LDarkseid1]

Impossible to grade without taking them out of the poly bags. Also, CGC doesn’t grade them unless they’re removed. So no one will able to provide any feedback until they’ve been removed.

[CHASEnBLUE]

I had these graded in the past. Carefully remove the polybag and keep the additional items with the detached poly in a separate polybag - only send the comic book to CGC. They will include on the label that the polybag was removed. When/if you sell the graded copy, you can include the polybag and contents with the purchase to the buyer. I have removed several polybags in my time and there is no penalty grade-wise, unless someone has a different experience.

Here is what one of mine looks like on the label...

 

[theCapraAegagrus]

NG.

[Spawnfreak]

7 hours ago, SellinMyCollection said:

Ok, grading these are... um difficult.  I have Adventure of Superman 500 and Superman 75 in poly bags.  I am not removing them so how are they graded?  Bagged and boarded since purchase.  Let me know your comments and feedback. I have no idea how to grade these except 9.8 but am I even close?
Thanks for looking

One book per post, per deadpoolica, or am I the one unable to post two?

[1950's war comics]

the bag looks to be in VG condition

[Deadpoolica]

13 hours ago, Spawnfreak said:

One book per post, per deadpoolica, or am I the one unable to post two?

You are correct; he needs to only post one book...The OP isn't going to get any helpful responses anyways with what he posted 

Edited January 15, 2021 by Deadpoolica

[Deadpoolica]

NG

[SellinMyCollection]

All

I apologize for posting 2 books.  My mistake. 
I was simply trying to get a feel about HOW to grade them. With them bagged I knew I couldn’t get a number.

I probably should have posted them in another thread, but this one appeared to be closest to what I needed.

Thank acegraphix. You intend me in the right direction which is what I need.

Everyone else, thanks for your replies and letting me know of my error. Wont happen again but thanks for reviewing 

[Spawnfreak]

10 hours ago, Deadpoolica said:

You are correct; he needs to only post one book...The OP isn't going to get any helpful responses anyways with what he posted 

And you are correct, sir! A few years ago, I acquired those same two comics in a collection, unbagged them, and no crease, lines, tics, nada. Lucky.

[SellinMyCollection]

Awesome Spawnfreak.  Hoping I am that lucky 

[Namtak]

No grade. Dont open it that much time in polybag aint good for books