PGM MTU 131 - White Rabbit 3 3

[Guy D. Corp]

What do you guys think? A few minor spine ticks, but the real concern is the circular crease that breaks color along the top edge. It is not a tear and is not dettached.

Thanks!

Edited February 3, 2021 by Guy D. Corp

[comicginger1789]

I think you mean Marvel Team Up #131.....

8.0-8.5 from me. That top crease is very noticeable. 

Edited February 3, 2021 by comicginger1789

[theCapraAegagrus]

8.0 IMO.

[Funnybooks]

8.0

[Deadpoolica]

7.5

[sagekilz]

7 - 7.5

[Mars76]

8.5-9.0. I've seen a few graded 9.0's with a similar crease. The rest of the book looks really nice to me. Theres a few tiny tics on the spine but that black cover looks nice and glossy. Cool cover too, I'm gonna look out and add that to my collection.

[ChrispyC66]

8.5

[Bayowolf]

8.5

[Guy D. Corp]

3 hours ago, Mars76 said:

8.5-9.0. I've seen a few graded 9.0's with a similar crease. The rest of the book looks really nice to me. Theres a few tiny tics on the spine but that black cover looks nice and glossy. Cool cover too, I'm gonna look out and add that to my collection.

My thought was 9.0, possible 8.5 if really harsh grader. I figure the crease knocks it down to 9.4 then the 4 tick marks push it down to 9.0. I think I’ll send it in just for the education aspect. 

[Galen130]

8.5

[Guy D. Corp]

Ok guys. This copy of Marvel Team-Up #131 just got graded. Here's the outcome including grader notes. Hope this is helpful to someone. I felt some of the opinions here that it was a 7.0-7.5 book were a bit harsh. And I was a bit optimistic in thinking it could still pull a 9.0. It was a beneficial journey for me, even though I'll only break even on the book.

CGC Cert # 3800401007

Grade: 8.5

Page Quality: WHITE

 

Grader Notes:

crease top of front cover breaks color
small crease left top of front cover breaks color
spine stress lines breaks color

 

 

[Mars76]

It looked like it had 9.0 potential. Still is a very cool and nice looking book.