Enough to be considered an error for O/C grade? 0

[Joshua Kim]

Hey guys do you think this card would get an O/C grade or is it just horribly centered. Any input is appreciated. Thanks CGC FAM!

(And yes I finally got a Shiny Charizard and it comes out like this) 

 

[gfelts88]

Wow your card looks exactly the same as the one I got lol. I think we just have some bad luck.

[Joshua Kim]

8 minutes ago, gfelts88 said:

Wow your card looks exactly the same as the one I got lol. I think we just have some bad luck.

I know what you mean. Still happy to have the card but damn! I'm wondering if my card would have a chance to get an 8 even though the centering is really off.

[gfelts88]

I'm probably gonna send mine off next week with a few other cards using walkthrough, i'll let ya know what it ends up getting. 

[GHFoster]

No, I think this would just get a poor grade on centering. Definitely still could get an 8 (or better) no doubt in my mind. 
 

Here’s some example cards I have. I’m not sure if the one on the left would receive an OC grade for centering, but I’m confident the second would and would be an error as well. 

Edited May 8, 2021 by GHFoster

[Joshua Kim]

9 minutes ago, GHFoster said:

No, I think this would just get a poor grade on centering. Definitely still could get an 8 (or better) no doubt in my mind. 
 

Here’s some example cards I have. I’m not sure if the one on the left would receive an OC grade for centering, but I’m confident the second would and would be an error as well. 

Good looking. Yeah I have seen some 8.5s and 9's with jacked up centering. Im hoping my other sub grades are strong so they could bring up the overall grade.

[gfelts88]

So mine got and 8.0 in centering but the other grades were still high enough to even it back out to a 9 overall.