PGM Wolverine Limited Series #1 2 2

[Emmkaaay]

Water-damaged, but otherwise excellent book. I have a hard time grading these flaws. Your input is appreciated!! Here is a link to detailed photos:

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1E7o_sND_7Mb7JTVq_5Qur3hFVnAFl0g9?usp=sharing

Thank you!

[scburdet]

We've discussed water damage/stains. You can probably do a search w/in this forum to find some good discussions. The search tools work pretty well.

From a CGC perspective, you would get hammered on this book. I see several stains on the front and back. I would expect 5.5±0.5. Other grading schemes may be more lenient, but CGC really hates stains.

[Emmkaaay]

On 7/30/2022 at 5:07 PM, scburdet said:

We've discussed water damage/stains. You can probably do a search w/in this forum to find some good discussions. The search tools work pretty well.

From a CGC perspective, you would get hammered on this book. I see several stains on the front and back. I would expect 5.5±0.5. Other grading schemes may be more lenient, but CGC really hates stains.

Thank you. I will check the existing discussions for sure. Just wanted to get some eyes on the actual book in question here. 

EDIT: Any links to existing threads appreciated. Search terms aren't bringing up relevant threads.

Edited July 31, 2022 by Emmkaaay
Requesting links to threads

[scburdet]

Here's one.

[scburdet]

Another. Type "stain" into the search bar, and use the drop down option to choose This Forum (otherwise you get a bunch of other stuff)

 

[grendelbo]

Back cover pics?

Is the water damage on both covers? Do the interior pages share the defect?

If it's the entire book I'm thinking 2.0-3.0.