Marvel chipping and regarding old slabbed book 1 1

[SpceWrnglr]

Thinking about having this book professionally deep cleaned and then resubmitting it to CGC. The book was originally graded and slabbed in 2012. I think if I were to crack it and resubmit it today, without the cleaning, with all the chipping it wouldn’t get the same grade. What are your thoughts on the chipping? From what I’ve read in CGC’s own official guide to grading, “marvel chipping” didn’t traditional affect grade too much, but today it’s viewed the same as any other missing piece. Do you think it will stay a 6.0 or is all the chipping gonna hit the grade hard? 

Grader Notes (2012)

Left Top Front Cover Small Piece Out
Right Bottom Front Cover Multiple Crease Breaks Color
Right Center Front Cover Marvel Chipping
Spine Wear Breaks Color

 

[CitrusZ28]

I would leave it as-is. I recently had my copy of FF #13 graded and it came out as 5.5, but in my MHO is better looking than this 6.0.

[SpceWrnglr]

On 10/26/2023 at 12:13 PM, CitrusZ28 said:

I would leave it as-is. I recently had my copy of FF #13 graded and it came out as 5.5, but in my MHO is better looking than this 6.0.

Agreed on both