Star Splangled Comics 75 1947 1 1

[mateus menor]

I bought this Star Splangled Comics 75 White Pagy from a friend for 90 dollars, and this comic was part of Marcio Escoteiro's collection: the biggest Batman collector in Brazil and one of the biggest in the world. Looking at it, what grade would you give it? It's worth sending it to CGC and pressing it.

Edited October 28, 2023 by mateus menor

[comicginger1789]

Cover appears detached or barely hanging on. Because of that combined with the other wear I think a 3.0 is best case scenario here . If the cover were firmly attached I could see as high as 4.0

As for whether it’s “worth it” to grade, you’d have to consider what a 3.0 sells for and determine if adding an additional $40-50 to do so is worth it on top of what you paid for it

[mateus menor]

Em 28/10/2023 às 20h52, comicginger1789 disse:

A capa parece destacada ou mal pendurada. Por causa disso, combinado com o outro desgaste, acho que um 3.0 é o melhor cenário aqui. Se a tampa estivesse firmemente fixada, eu poderia ver até 4,0

Quanto a saber se “vale a pena” avaliar, você teria que considerar quanto custa um 3.0 e determinar se vale a pena adicionar US $ 40-50 adicionais para fazer isso além do que você pagou por ele

But this one was part of Marcio Escoteiro's collection and still has white pages, so it's worth a lot more than a normal 3.0

Edited October 28, 2023 by mateus menor

[JollyComics]

On 10/28/2023 at 6:54 PM, mateus menor said:

But this one was part of Marcio Escoteiro's collection and still has white pages, so it's worth a lot more than a normal 3.0

Ola!  True, but the page quality has nothing to do with the grade.  Third party grading company will give it White Pages instead of the grade.

I agreed with Comicginger1789 about 3.0 for this book.   Overstreet Price Guide shows 2.0 = $74 and 4.0 = $148  for Star Spangled #75.  You bought it for $90 is about right.

[mateus menor]

On 28/10/2023 at 21:14, JollyComics said:

Olá! É verdade, mas a qualidade da página não tem nada a ver com a nota. A empresa de classificação terceirizada fornecerá páginas em branco em vez da nota.

Concordei com Comicginger1789 sobre 3.0 para este livro. O Guia de Preços Overstreet mostra 2,0 = $ 74 e 4,0 = $ 148 para Star Spangled #75. Você comprou por US $ 90 está certo.

So white pages don't increase the value?

[JollyComics]

On 10/28/2023 at 7:35 PM, mateus menor said:

So white pages don't increase the value?

No, but they intend to buy books with White Pages.  White pages attract the buyers easily.

[mateus menor]

On 10/28/2023 at 9:41 PM, JollyComics said:

No, but they intend to buy books with White Pages.  White pages attract the buyers easily.

But you can't ignore the fact that it belonged to Marcio Escoteiro's collection

[JollyComics]

On 10/28/2023 at 7:53 PM, mateus menor said:

But you can't ignore the fact that it belonged to Marcio Escoteiro's collection

Do you have COA?

[mateus menor]

On 28/10/2023 at 21:59, JollyComics said:

Você tem COA?

Everyone tells me this, how do I get the COA?

[JollyComics]

On 10/28/2023 at 8:01 PM, mateus menor said:

Everyone tells me this, how do I get the COA?

The collector should make the COA.   Otherwise the dealer must purchase the whole collection and would make the COA.

You bought it without the COA.  I don't know who Marcio Escoteiro is.

[mateus menor]

On 28/10/2023 at 22:06, JollyComics said:

O coletor deverá fazer o COA. Caso contrário o revendedor deverá adquirir toda a coleção e fará o COA.

Você comprou sem o COA. Não sei quem é Márcio Escoteiro.

Marcio Escoteiro had an immense collection that included comics from the most varied countries, toys, rare materials used in Batman television and film productions, he contributed his knowledge and material to various publications and events, with emphasis on Batman 80, even Ivan Reis provided tribute to him in DC 1027. He had between 6 and 7 thousand items in his collection, see report about the collection here: https://terraverso.com.br/especial-batman-80-anos-conheca-o-maior- collector-of-batman-items-in-brazil/

[mateus menor]

On 28/10/2023 at 22:06, JollyComics said:

O coletor deverá fazer o COA. Caso contrário o revendedor deverá adquirir toda a coleção e fará o COA.

Você comprou sem o COA. Não sei quem é Márcio Escoteiro.

I'm a friend of the predecessor of Marcio Escoteiro's collection, how can he make the COA for this collection?

[mateus menor]

On 28/10/2023 at 20:52, comicginger1789 said:

A capa parece destacada ou mal pendurada. Por causa disso, combinado com o outro desgaste, acho que um 3.0 é o melhor cenário aqui. Se a tampa estivesse firmemente fixada, eu poderia ver até 4,0

Quanto a saber se “vale a pena” avaliar, você teria que considerar quanto custa um 3.0 e determinar se vale a pena adicionar US $ 40-50 adicionais para fazer isso além do que você pagou por ele

HI, I looked at my comic more closely today, and the cover is not detached or hanging badly. Is it worth sending then?

[JollyComics]

On 10/29/2023 at 9:12 AM, mateus menor said:

HI, I looked at my comic more closely today, and the cover is not detached or hanging badly. Is it worth sending then?

GPAnalysis.com