Help grading my Amazing Spider-Man #3 please

[popnecker]

 

[RDK]

Oh man, that's a pity. Still, I suppose keeping it in a binder (holes and all) is what kept the rest of the book looking as nice as it is.

[Aces]

6.5Q

 

[marvelcollector]

0.5...

 

Ignoring the holes - and that's hard to do (other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play? ) - looks like it might have been a 6.5....

[popnecker]

I do keep trying to ingnore those binder holes, but they just won't go away..! I don't think this is from the John Wilkes Booth collection by the way...imagine THAT pedigree...

 

Any idea how much CGC Qualified effects value? Not sure it's worth slabbing.

[Psiknight]

I do keep trying to ingnore those binder holes, but they just won't go away..! I don't think this is from the John Wilkes Booth collection by the way...imagine THAT pedigree...

 

Any idea how much CGC Qualified effects value? Not sure it's worth slabbing.

 

Certainly not worth getting slabbed. I wouldn't pay 2.0 price for that...but that's just me.

[KingOfRulers]

Looks like a 2.5 to me.

[-cryptkeeper-]

I don't know if CGC could consider it as qualified, i consider binder as important cover trauma then no more than 1.8 ,that's just my p.o.v

[mar-vell]

tough break! hard to look at! Wonder if such a book is worth restoring? probably not because pro resto fees are so high-probably would be the best thing that could happen to the book though because those binder holes are pretty much universally loathed!

[Kermit the frog]

 

 

[Mephisto]

I don't know if CGC could consider it as qualified, i consider binder as important cover trauma then no more than 1.8 ,that's just my p.o.v

 

I have seen some books with binder holes get the green label before.

[comicnut]

Those are some seriously traumatized binder holes. It looks like someone tried pulling the book out without opening the rings!!!

1.8 folks

Come on now you can't give this a 0.5 poor. That grade is reserved for incomplete and fragile books or just plain ugly! Tell ya what if you have or get any books that are like this I'll gladly buy them off you as 0.5's!!!

This isn't that bad. Take the defects for what they are. Small pieces missing on front and back cover take it down to a 2.5 to 3.0, the pieces missing off the pages take it down to 1.8.