ComicSupply Grading Contest v2 Round 3/4/5 Underway

[ComicSupply]

Ok, here are the next 3 books. Grades are due into me by Friday at 9pm est.

Grader note's have not been called in on. PM your grades/questions to me along with your alias/teamname. Carefully study the scans, all defects are shown. Hitting a grade on the head equals a Win, missing equals a loss.

 

Round 3 book: New blue label. White Pages:

 

 

Round 4 book: New blue label. White Pages:

 

 

Round 5 book: New blue label. OW/W Pages:

[awe4one]

Is that slab damage along the top of the Cap America?

 

Jim

[ComicSupply]

Nope, that is the book.

[Comicdey]

pm sent

[osborn_fr]

pm sent

 

Do we have to post in this thread that the grades were PM to you

 

No, no reason to eat up the thread and make it 10 pgs long.

 

[Fan4Fan]

pm sent

 

Do we have to post in this thread that the grades were PM to you

 

No, no reason to eat up the thread and make it 10 pgs long.

 

 

Yeah, save those 10 pages for whining about rules violations...

[osborn_fr]

[Johnny G]

PM Sent!

[Johnny G]

Hey Russ,

 

I hope that the DC Comics Presents #56 isn't the one I ordered when it was listed as the Treasure Hunt in Wizard (and I quickly jumped on it)... becuase from what you told me it was a rag(listed for sale as NM!) and that's why it couldn't be shipped and I was refunded!

 

1 x DC Comics Presents #56 $2.99 (from order history and refunded)

 

But I know that's not what happened because that wouldn't be cool at all! Right???

 

 

[ComicSupply]

Hey Russ,

 

I hope that the DC Comics Presents #56 isn't the one I ordered when it was listed as the Treasure Hunt in Wizard (and I quickly jumped on it)... becuase from what you told me it was a rag(listed for sale as NM!) and that's why it couldn't be shipped and I was refunded!

 

1 x DC Comics Presents #56 $2.99 (from order history and refunded)

 

But I know that's not what happened because that wouldn't be cool at all! Right???

 

 

No, that was the 9.9 I got

 

This just came from a collection we got in mid-late December. We have about 5-6 of them now as this collection had a ton of duplicates and this was the best one worth sending in.

[Johnny G]

Hey Russ,

 

I hope that the DC Comics Presents #56 isn't the one I ordered when it was listed as the Treasure Hunt in Wizard (and I quickly jumped on it)... becuase from what you told me it was a rag(listed for sale as NM!) and that's why it couldn't be shipped and I was refunded!

 

1 x DC Comics Presents #56 $2.99 (from order history and refunded)

 

But I know that's not what happened because that wouldn't be cool at all! Right???

 

 

No, that was the 9.9 I got

 

This just came from a collection we got in mid-late December. We have about 5-6 of them now as this collection had a ton of duplicates and this was the best one worth sending in.

 

 

[Pirate]

Hey Russ,

 

I hope that the DC Comics Presents #56 isn't the one I ordered when it was listed as the Treasure Hunt in Wizard (and I quickly jumped on it)... becuase from what you told me it was a rag(listed for sale as NM!) and that's why it couldn't be shipped and I was refunded!

 

1 x DC Comics Presents #56 $2.99 (from order history and refunded)

 

But I know that's not what happened because that wouldn't be cool at all! Right???

 

 

No, that was the 9.9 I got

 

This just came from a collection we got in mid-late December. We have about 5-6 of them now as this collection had a ton of duplicates and this was the best one worth sending in.

 

aah so you admit the book is good, so it must be a 9.2 or higher. great now i have a 1 in 4 chance of sucess. muahahaahaahahahha

[ComicSupply]

Hey Russ,

 

I hope that the DC Comics Presents #56 isn't the one I ordered when it was listed as the Treasure Hunt in Wizard (and I quickly jumped on it)... becuase from what you told me it was a rag(listed for sale as NM!) and that's why it couldn't be shipped and I was refunded!

 

1 x DC Comics Presents #56 $2.99 (from order history and refunded)

 

But I know that's not what happened because that wouldn't be cool at all! Right???

 

 

No, that was the 9.9 I got

 

This just came from a collection we got in mid-late December. We have about 5-6 of them now as this collection had a ton of duplicates and this was the best one worth sending in.

 

aah so you admit the book is good, so it must be a 9.2 or higher. great now i have a 1 in 4 chance of sucess. muahahaahaahahahha

Not necessarily.

[ronm3-migration]

Grades sent.

[Aces]

Grades sent.

 

Me too!

[Warlord]

All grades not in yet? Who needs to get cracking?

[Norrin_Radd]

All grades not in yet? Who needs to get cracking?

Not me?

[Timulty]

Not me. That lucky bastiche Dr. Evil probably hasn't turned in his/her scores.

[Norrin_Radd]

Not me. That lucky bastiche Dr. Evil probably hasn't turned in his/her scores.

 

Probably.

[ComicSupply]

Remember, deadline to send in grades is tonight at 9pm est. 12 left to send in grades. Results will be posted sometime late tonight as will the new round.