Horse Game - New Rules !!!

[143ksk]

Horse #9: Joe Kubert

[GACollectibles]

Hows about:

 

#1 Jack Cole

#6 Bernie Krigstein

 

[Sal]

Horse 17 Joe Kubert

Horse 18 Carl Banks (?) or Don Rosa, I guess

Horse 21 John Buscema

Horse 27 Gil Kane

Horse 28 Looks like Frank Thorne

Horse 31 Al Williamson (?)

Horse 32 Stan Sakai

Horse 33 Arthur Adams

Horse 40 Frazetta

Horse 42 Kurtzmann

Horse 43 Neal Adams

 

oh, and you realise you need to update the first post when a correct answer is given...

[GACollectibles]

Are we posting guesses on all right now or just on the 1st 10?

[bobpfef]

My guesses:

13 Jack Davis

16 Toth

18 Rosa

20 Barks

23 Eisner

25 Kriegstein

36 DeBeck

40 Frazetta

42 Kurtzman

43 Adams

45 Gottfredson

[Scrooge]

Are we posting guesses on all right now or just on the 1st 10?

 

Heck let's make it all 50. I'll try to update the guesses as we go along. FREE FOR ALL !!!

[GACollectibles]

#1 Jack Cole

#6 Bernie Krigstein

#9 Kubert

#17 Kubert

#18 Rosa?

#23 Eisner

#40 Frazetta

#42 Kurtzman

#45 Gottfredson

[Scrooge]

Recap of guesses so far -

 

Horse 1 - Jack Cole to GAC, Timulty [People guessed CC Beck twice]

Horse 2 -

Horse 3 -

Horse 4 -

Horse 5 - Joe Maneely to DL

Horse 6 - Bernard Krigstein to GAC

Horse 7 - Hal Foster on Prince Valiant to GAC

Horse 8

Horse 9 - Joe Kubert to GAC, 143

Horse 10

Horse 11

Horse 12

Horse 13 - Jack Davis to BobP

Horse 14

Horse 15

Horse 16 - Not Toth

Horse 17 - Joe Kubert to GAC, Sal

Horse 18 - Don Rosa to GAC, BobP, Sal

Horse 19

Horse 20 - Carl Barks to BobP [People guessed DeBeck twice]

Horse 21 - Not Buscema

Horse 22

Horse 23 - Will Eisner to GAC, BobP

Horse 24

Horse 25 - Not Krigstein

Horse 26

Horse 27

Horse 28 - Not Frank Thorne

Horse 29

Horse 30

Horse 31 - Ralph Mayo with Williamson inks to Sal

Horse 32 - Stan Sakai to Sal

Horse 33 - Not Art Adams interesting guess

Horse 34

Horse 35

Horse 36 - Not DeBeck (I think)

Horse 37

Horse 38

Horse 39

Horse 40 - Frank Frazetta to Timulty, GAC, BobP, Sal

Horse 41

Horse 42 - Harvey Kurtzman to GAC, BobP, Sal

Horse 43 - Neal Adams to BobP, Sal

Horse 44

Horse 45 - Floyd Gottfredson to GAC, BobP

Horse 46

Horse 47

Horse 48

Horse 49

Horse 50

[GACollectibles]

#7 Foster?

[Scrooge]

Yessir on Prince Valiant from Sunday May 22, 1937 - Early in the strip - Will update list above.

[GACollectibles]

#36 Warren Kremer

[143ksk]

22: Frazetta?

25 and 27 Gil Kane

35 and 44 Alex Toth

[bobpfef]

35 and 44 Alex Toth

 

I second 35 as Toth though I don't think 44 is

[bobpfef]

11 - Raymond ?

[HouseofComics.Com]

Shoot, I wrote out my list first before looking but it seems I only got the obvious ones. I got the Kubert and Eisner and Adams and Frazetta. I too guessed Toth for 16. Was wrong with Barks for 18, not Rosa. (Went by the noses. I need to study their button noses more to be able to tell them apart--an important skill!)

 

I am with 143ksk on 25 and 27. In my notes I put that 25 was Kane-ish. Also, #27 somehow reminds me of the Aurora Comic Scenes Lone Ranger, which is done by Kane. So I say Kane for that too.

 

So the only guess I have to add is #34, Moebius.

 

Plus a hint--I think we need to come up with some guesses from the Atlas stable, as Atlas published lots of westerns. So Severin, Ayers, Heath, etc. Gosh, you'd think there'd be a Kirby horse in there somewhere!

 

Another hint--we've sold lots of European western albums, meaning most modern westerns are published abroad. So that's another source Scrooge is almost certainly drawing from.

 

Fuuuun thread.

 

Marc

[Sal]

8 - Eisner? man, it looks familiar

21 not Buscema, maybe Barry Windsor-Smith?

25 Kirby?

28 Wood?

30 looks like Kirby/Coletta

46 looks Kaluta-esque

...but probably all incorrect

 

please note i had Kane on 27 originally, so thhpppbbbbt.

[Arty]

damn too late...

 

Horse 15 - Alex Raymond...maybe

Horse 18 - Don Rosa

Horse 20 - Carl Barks

Horse 38 - Rosa

Horse 40 - Frazetta

Horse 42 - MAD artist Kurtzman perhaps

Horse 45 - Gottfredson

[Scrooge]

Updated Recap so far - Updated with source of scans -

 

Horse 1 - Jack Cole from Plastic Man # 1 to GAC, Timulty [People guessed CC Beck twice]

Horse 2 -

Horse 3 -

Horse 4 -

Horse 5 - Joe Maneely from Black Knight # 3 to DL

Horse 6 - Bernard Krigstein from War Action # 12 to GAC

Horse 7 - Hal Foster on Prince Valiant - Sunday May 22, 1937 to GAC

Horse 8 - Not Eisner

Horse 9 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 to GAC, 143, HoC

Horse 10

Horse 11 - Alex Raymond from Flash Gordon Nov. 27, 1935 to BobP

Horse 12

Horse 13 - Jack Davis from Frontline Combat # 5 to BobP

Horse 14

Horse 15 - Not Raymond

Horse 16 - Not Toth

Horse 17 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 Cover to GAC, Sal, HoC

Horse 18 - Don Rosa from Life & Time Ep. 3 to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 19

Horse 20 - Carl Barks from Sheriff of Bullet Valley to BobP, Arty [People guessed DeBeck twice]

Horse 21 - Barry Smith from Conan # 14 to Sal [First guess was Buscema]

Horse 22 - Not Frazetta [Guessed Frazetta twice]

Horse 23 - Will Eisner from Caramba! Spirit Section Nov 10, 1946 to GAC, BobP, HoC

Horse 24

Horse 25 - Gil Kane from Conan # 18 to 143, HoC Note: Look at those nostrils!!! That's the clue. [Guessed as Krigstein and Kirby]

Horse 26

Horse 27 - Gil Kane from Kid-Colt Outlaw # 206 to 143, Sal and HoC

Horse 28 - Not Frank Thorne nor Wally Wood

Horse 29

Horse 30 - Jack Kirby with Colletta inks from Tales of Asgard in JIM # 109 to Sal [First Kirby found - 2 more to go ]

Horse 31 - Ralph Mayo with Williamson inks from Six-Gun Western # 2 to Sal

Horse 32 - Stan Sakai from Usagi Yojimbo - The Confession to Sal

Horse 33 - Not Art Adams interesting guess

Horse 34 - Not Moebius - This is a tough one

Horse 35 - Not Toth

Horse 36 - Warren Kremer from Casper and Nightmare # 46 to GAC[Guessed as DeBeck]

Horse 37

Horse 38 - Don Rosa in Life & Time Ep. 6B Pizzen Bluff to Arty [Notice similarity with Horse # 33]

Horse 39

Horse 40 - Frank Frazetta to Timulty, GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty, HoC

Horse 41

Horse 42 - Harvey Kurtzman from Billy the Kid # 9 - Pot Shot Pete strip to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 43 - Neal Adams from Tomahawk # 116 to BobP, Sal, HoC

Horse 44 - Not Toth

Horse 45 - Floyd Gottfredson from Mickey Mouse strip circa Jan 1933 to GAC, BobP, Arty

Horse 46 - Not Kaluta

Horse 47

Horse 48

Horse 49

Horse 50

[Scrooge]

damn too late...

 

Never too late. You're the first to find the second Don Rosa in there plus I updated your guesses as well as HoC. Sal and GAC are ahead it seems.

 

Oh, there are no European artists in there. I knew better than that. There are left in there only GA and SA artists. No more modern Rosa or Sakai type guys. There are 2 more Kirbys and other usual suspects ...Names have floated around but not with the correct horse ... Someone looks at Horse # 37 and catch that one fast, it's the low hanging fruit left with # 26 I'd say.

[Aman619]

#37 is Moultom Marston, (sp) GA Wonder Woman artist but its a recolored modern printing