Horse Game - New Rules !!!

[Aman619]

44 is Kirby

[Aman619]

3 = Ayers?

4 = Frazetta (by the hooves)

[Aman619]

10 = Severin?

12 = Jack Davis

14 = TOTH!!!

[Aman619]

24 = Wood?

47 = Buscema??

 

beats me on the rest, pardnuh!

[Aman619]

33 = = I originally had MWKaluta, but the fine brushwork now says Frazetta. (ALso looks like GHOST RIDER behind the horse)

[Scrooge]

Updated Recap so far - Updated with source of scans -

 

Horse 1 - Jack Cole from Plastic Man # 1 to GAC, Timulty [People guessed CC Beck twice]

Horse 2 -

Horse 3 - Not Ayers

Horse 4 - Hal Foster - Prince Valiant - May 2, 1937 Sunday to me. I mixed it up with the Tarzan in # 7 for a minute. [Not Frazetta]

Horse 5 - Joe Maneely from Black Knight # 3 to DL

Horse 6 - Bernard Krigstein from War Action # 12 to GAC

Horse 7 - Hal Foster on Tarzan - Jan 29, 1933 Sunday to GAC

Horse 8 - Not Eisner

Horse 9 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 to GAC, 143, HoC

Horse 10 - John Severin from Ringo Kid Western # 2 to Aman

Horse 11 - Alex Raymond from Flash Gordon Nov. 27, 1935 to BobP

Horse 12 - Not Jack Davis

Horse 13 - Jack Davis from Frontline Combat # 5 to BobP

Horse 14 - Alex Toth from All-american Western # 117 Cover to Aman

Horse 15 - Not Raymond

Horse 16 - Not Toth

Horse 17 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 Cover to GAC, Sal, HoC

Horse 18 - Don Rosa from Life & Time Ep. 3 to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 19

Horse 20 - Carl Barks from Sheriff of Bullet Valley to BobP, Arty [People guessed DeBeck twice]

Horse 21 - Barry Smith from Conan # 14 to Sal [First guess was Buscema]

Horse 22 - Not Frazetta [Guessed Frazetta twice]

Horse 23 - Will Eisner from Caramba! Spirit Section Nov 10, 1946 to GAC, BobP, HoC

Horse 24 - Not Wally Wood

Horse 25 - Gil Kane from Conan # 18 to 143, HoC Note: Look at those nostrils!!! That's the clue. [Guessed as Krigstein and Kirby]

Horse 26

Horse 27 - Gil Kane from Kid-Colt Outlaw # 206 to 143, Sal and HoC

Horse 28 - Not Frank Thorne nor Wally Wood

Horse 29

Horse 30 - Jack Kirby with Colletta inks from Tales of Asgard in JIM # 109 to Sal [First Kirby found]

Horse 31 - Ralph Mayo with Williamson inks from Six-Gun Western # 2 to Sal

Horse 32 - Stan Sakai from Usagi Yojimbo - The Confession to Sal

Horse 33 - Frank Frazetta from Ghost Rider # 4 Cover to Aman [Not Art Adams]

Horse 34 - Not Moebius - This is a tough one

Horse 35 - Not Toth

Horse 36 - Warren Kremer from Casper and Nightmare # 46 to GAC[Guessed as DeBeck]

Horse 37 - H. G. Peter from Cover of Alter Ego # 23 to Aman [Marston was the creator / writer to Peter's pencils]

Horse 38 - Don Rosa in Life & Time Ep. 6B Pizzen Bluff to Arty [Notice similarity with Horse # 33]

Horse 39

Horse 40 - Frank Frazetta to Timulty, GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty, HoC

Horse 41

Horse 42 - Harvey Kurtzman from Billy the Kid # 9 - Pot Shot Pete strip to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 43 - Neal Adams from Tomahawk # 116 to BobP, Sal, HoC

Horse 44 - S & K from Boy's Ranch # 1 Cover to Aman [Was guessed as Toth] [second Kirby found - 1 more to go ]

Horse 45 - Floyd Gottfredson from Mickey Mouse strip circa Jan 1933 to GAC, BobP, Arty

Horse 46 - Not Kaluta

Horse 47 - John Buscema from Conan # 25 to Aman

Horse 48

Horse 49

Horse 50

[Scrooge]

beats me on the rest, pardnuh!

 

Heck, you added 5 correct guesses. Some to be proud for sure.

 

You all let me know when you are ready for hints ...

[Scrooge]

Also, I'd love to hear from you all now that you've had a chance to look those hosses over very closely which depictions you like best.

[HouseofComics.Com]

Very tricky putting in a Kirby Asgardian horse!

[Aman619]

beats me on the rest, pardnuh!

 

Heck, you added 5 correct guesses. Some to be proud for sure.

 

You all let me know when you are ready for hints ...

 

thanx. The rest are too 'obscure' for me.

Bring on the SuperHeroes!

[Arty]

Horse 15 -

 

 

I'm really curious who drew this, I really like his style. Smooth and clean.

[Paris_Fred]

At first glance:

 

Horse 15: Raboy

Horse 16: Kane

Horse 19: Wood, cover to valor 1

Horse 22: Kinstler

Horse 28: Kubert

Horse 35: Estrada

Horse 41: Severin

Horse 50: Kubert

[Aman619]

50 = Kubert! I think youre right!! Its got the beginnings of his "slicked down" later style...

Yes or no Scrooge???

[Aman619]

Horse 15 -

 

 

I'm really curious who drew this, I really like his style. Smooth and clean.

 

at one point, I was thinking Virgil Finlay... but its not elegant enough somehow..

[Scrooge]

Updated Recap so far - Updated with source of scans -

 

Horse 1 - Jack Cole from Plastic Man # 1 to GAC, Timulty [People guessed CC Beck twice]

Horse 2 -

Horse 3 - Not Ayers

Horse 4 - Hal Foster - Prince Valiant - May 2, 1937 Sunday to me. I mixed it up with the Tarzan in # 7 for a minute. [Not Frazetta]

Horse 5 - Joe Maneely from Black Knight # 3 to DL

Horse 6 - Bernard Krigstein from War Action # 12 to GAC

Horse 7 - Hal Foster on Tarzan - Jan 29, 1933 Sunday to GAC

Horse 8 - Not Eisner

Horse 9 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 to GAC, 143, HoC

Horse 10 - John Severin from Ringo Kid Western # 2 to Aman

Horse 11 - Alex Raymond from Flash Gordon Nov. 27, 1935 to BobP

Horse 12 - Not Jack Davis

Horse 13 - Jack Davis from Frontline Combat # 5 to BobP

Horse 14 - Alex Toth from All-american Western # 117 Cover to Aman

Horse 15 - Mac Raboy - Flash Gordon July 17, 1949 to PFred - Can't fault the earlier guess of Raymond

Horse 16 - Not Toth nor Kane

Horse 17 - Joe Kubert from Tarzan # 220 Cover to GAC, Sal, HoC

Horse 18 - Don Rosa from Life & Time Ep. 3 to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 19 - Wally Wood from Valor # 1 Cover - to PFred

Horse 20 - Carl Barks from Sheriff of Bullet Valley to BobP, Arty [People guessed DeBeck twice]

Horse 21 - Barry Smith from Conan # 14 to Sal [First guess was Buscema]

Horse 22 - Everett Raymond Kinstler - Jesse James Interior Cover to PFred [Guessed Frazetta twice]

Horse 23 - Will Eisner from Caramba! Spirit Section Nov 10, 1946 to GAC, BobP, HoC

Horse 24 - Not Wally Wood

Horse 25 - Gil Kane from Conan # 18 to 143, HoC Note: Look at those nostrils!!! That's the clue. [Guessed as Krigstein and Kirby]

Horse 26

Horse 27 - Gil Kane from Kid-Colt Outlaw # 206 to 143, Sal and HoC

Horse 28 - Not Frank Thorne nor Wally Wood nor Joe Kubert

Horse 29

Horse 30 - Jack Kirby with Colletta inks from Tales of Asgard in JIM # 109 to Sal [First Kirby found]

Horse 31 - Ralph Mayo with Williamson inks from Six-Gun Western # 2 to Sal

Horse 32 - Stan Sakai from Usagi Yojimbo - The Confession to Sal

Horse 33 - Frank Frazetta from Ghost Rider # 4 Cover to Aman [Not Art Adams]

Horse 34 - Not Moebius - This is a tough one

Horse 35 - Not Toth nor Rick Estrada

Horse 36 - Warren Kremer from Casper and Nightmare # 46 to GAC[Guessed as DeBeck]

Horse 37 - H. G. Peter from Cover of Alter Ego # 23 to Aman [Marston was the creator / writer to Peter's pencils]

Horse 38 - Don Rosa in Life & Time Ep. 6B Pizzen Bluff to Arty [Notice similarity with Horse # 33]

Horse 39

Horse 40 - Frank Frazetta to Timulty, GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty, HoC

Horse 41 - John Severin from Prize Western Comics # 96 to PFred

Horse 42 - Harvey Kurtzman from Billy the Kid # 9 - Pot Shot Pete strip to GAC, BobP, Sal, Arty

Horse 43 - Neal Adams from Tomahawk # 116 to BobP, Sal, HoC

Horse 44 - S & K from Boy's Ranch # 1 Cover to Aman [Was guessed as Toth] [second Kirby found - 1 more to go ]

Horse 45 - Floyd Gottfredson from Mickey Mouse strip circa Jan 1933 to GAC, BobP, Arty

Horse 46 - Not Kaluta

Horse 47 - John Buscema from Conan # 25 to Aman

Horse 48

Horse 49

Horse 50 - Joe Kubert indeed from All-American Western # 114 to PFred - Closer to his younger days on Hawkman than the Tarzan showcased above

[Scrooge]

At first glance:

 

Here are Fred's correct additions to the hit list

 

Horse 15: Raboy

Horse 19: Wood, cover to valor 1

Horse 22: Kinstler

Horse 41: Severin

Horse 50: Kubert

 

5 tough ones with an origin ID so you have well deserved

 

That undersea sea-horses romp is by Raboy and it is a different Kubert on # 50.

 

Left are -

 

Horse 2 -

Horse 3 - Not Ayers

Horse 8 - Not Eisner

Horse 12 - Not Jack Davis

Horse 16 - Not Toth nor Kane

Horse 24 - Not Wally Wood

Horse 26

Horse 28 - Not Frank Thorne nor Wally Wood nor Joe Kubert

Horse 29

Horse 34 - Not Moebius - This is a tough one

Horse 35 - Not Toth nor Rick Estrada

Horse 39

Horse 46 - Not Kaluta

Horse 48

Horse 49

 

Out of those 15 horses, more than half are repeat artists whose other horse has already been identified and about 6 or 7 "new" names.

[Timulty]

You know, I don't see Milton Caniff represented in any of the answers. I wonder if he has a horse on here.

[HouseofComics.Com]

Horse 47 -

 

 

From Conan 25, you say? I read this recently and IIRC, there are some great horse shots early on, including page one. This one seems a little pedestrian.

 

Lots of Conan in here. Do you have issues 1-100 Scrooge?

 

Marc

[GACollectibles]

I gotta get more Mac Raboy stuff, those two panels are nice!

[Sal]

is 46 Frazetta/Williamson?