PGM Adventure Comics 247

[Forbush-Man]

Nice Fine+ book except there is a 2 1/2" cover split along the spine from the bottom staple down. Cover and all pages attached at both staples. Small sliver missing from bottom right corner of front cover (visble in scan). Otherwise nice, tight and flat. What would it grade?

 

 

 

[Stout1a]

Though it looks nice. With what I can see and your description Id go 4.0 Tops... Still a nice looking book..

[buttock]

I kind of feel like this is the type of book that gets a "+" added at the end of the grade - if for no other reason than it looks nicer than it's technical grade. Technically with the split, it's probably no better than 4.0, but I wouldn't feel awful about calling it a "VG+" just because it looks nicer.

[Aces]

Looks like the split goes up from the bottom staple a ways too.

 

A real nice 4.0.

[-cryptkeeper-]

no more than 3.0 with such a split

[Norrin_Radd]

Seems kinda of pixelated, but I'd say 3.5.

[Forbush-Man]

Seems kinda of pixelated, but I'd say 3.5.

 

 

[B-Smooth]

this is a tough one. Its a nice looking book but that spine split and the missing chunk hurts it badly. Ill be generous because of how it presents itself so nicely. 4.5

[KingOfRulers]

I say 3.5!

[esquirecomics]

I kind of feel like this is the type of book that gets a "+" added at the end of the grade - if for no other reason than it looks nicer than it's technical grade. Technically with the split, it's probably no better than 4.0, but I wouldn't feel awful about calling it a "VG+" just because it looks nicer.

 

Geez, actually by Overstreet standards, that split brings it down to a 1.5 -2.0. If it weren't for that (and the little missing sliver), this book is nice sweet mid-grade copy that could grade a 6.0. Because of what book it is, and the otherwise nice eye appeal, I would predict CGC would give it a 3.5/4.0.