Green Label SHOULD NOT affect collectability...

[THE_BEYONDER]

" Marvel value stamp was cut out of 10th page, DOES NOT EFFECT STORY. This did earn it a green (incomplete) label, however, I am told this SHOULD NOT effect collectability. "

 

 

Qualified

[murph0]

I should email him and see if he'll buy my ASM books with some ads cut out..at full price of course though..because missing parts of the book, DON'T EFFECT COLLECTABILITY.

 

Brian

[supapimp]

i just saw this auction why surfin on eBay, im curious as to what i will close at, if it does.

[Darthdiesel]

Yeah the seller is using a spin on a common thinking on the Green Qualified label. The Green label alone should not "affect" collectability (as with signed comics like DF exclusives), it is the Green label combined with the INCOMPLETE note that does a comic value in almost as much as a PLOD.

[supapimp]

Yeah the seller is using a spin on a common thinking on the Green Qualified label. The Green label alone should not "affect" collectability (as with signed comics like DF exclusives), it is the Green label combined with the INCOMPLETE note that does a comic value in almost as much as a PLOD.

 

geez, that sure sounded like an overstreet advisor.

[Darthdiesel]

Yeah the seller is using a spin on a common thinking on the Green Qualified label. The Green label alone should not "affect" collectability (as with signed comics like DF exclusives), it is the Green label combined with the INCOMPLETE note that does a comic value in almost as much as a PLOD.

 

geez, that sure sounded like an overstreet advisor.

 

The only advisor with Prada Bondage pants, thank you very much....

[ninanina]

Someone needs to buy this and that 1.0, and do a cover switch. Unfortuneatley with that $600.00 minimum and the rediculous price that 1.0 is already going for, you might break even.

 

So, what's a Qualified 9.0 Hulk 181 go for these days.

 

Not $600.00?

[THE_BEYONDER]

What do you think a CGC HULK 181 9.8 would go for with a QUALIFIED label because the MARVEL VALUE STAMP was cut out?

[Darthdiesel]

$1K - $1.2K; not likely though - why would anyone preserve a book to the point that it deserves a 9.8 after they purposefully cut out what they felt was the most important part of the book ( the stamp) - scenario not likely but my opinion is up top. I think supapimp won a qualified CGC 9.2 from Scottish with the Marvel stamp cut out on eBay for around $415?

[supapimp]

I think supa bought a qualified from Scottsih on here - might have been a Q CGC 9.4 for around $750?

 

WRONG!

[Darthdiesel]

fixed it,

[shadroch]

If someone replaced the mvs and resubmitted this book it would get a PLOD. It would then sell for less. Does anyone think this makes sense? Bill

[Darthdiesel]

Yes...makes sense in most cases. but if you buy it and "restore" the Marvel Stamp of Shanna the She Devil ( which I heard can be found in several concurrent comics,like a much cheaper FF that came out in March of 74 and sell raw complete, then you'd probably get more money than if it was slabbed green or purple.You'll get many folks dreaming of sollar signs that will bite on it.