FF 48 How about that silver surfer guy.

[Comicdey]

FF 48

[Mr. Zipper]

5.5

 

Small water stain on back cover probably doesn't make a difference in this grade.

 

Grade would be revised if that is a tear below Johnny's feet.

[Comicdey]

Not a tear.

[KingOfRulers]

5.5

[Point Five]

Nice book!, but I'd say 5.0 with the stain, maybe even 4.5 if the back pages are affected.

[Kermit the frog]

Nice book!, but I'd say 5.0 with the stain, maybe even 4.5 if the back pages are affected.

 

ditto...water stain brings it back more to the 4.0 to 4.5 imho. without it it could go 5.5 at best.

 

regards

[-cryptkeeper-]

I think 5.0 sounds fair for this one, water stain is not enough important to bring it down to 4.0 or 4.5

[Aces]

5.0

[Comicdey]

By the way, I've already got a copy of this one, so ......it will be in the market forum at some point awaiting offers. Or maybe I should sell my other copy as it doesn' t have the water stain.

[joeypost]

5.5

[uclapeterg]

4.5.

[Comicdey]

Please compare this one to the other and give me an opinion on which one you'd keep of the two?

[Point Five]

This copy looks sharper, and the small stain on the back isn't a dealbreaker for me. Probably this one, though it depends on the page quality too.

[KingOfRulers]

I'd keep this copy of the two. While it has a stain, it is on the back. Put it in a bag and board, and its almost like the stain isn't there.

[Aces]

Please compare this one to the other and give me an opinion on which one you'd keep of the two?

 

Stain ruins this one and the spine wear is bad on the other.

I gave them both a 5.0.

 

I would sell them both and use the funds to get a nice white page 6.5-7.5.

[uclapeterg]

I would keep the other one.

[finecomics]

I'd sell both and cheap at that

[divad]

I'd sell both and cheap at that

 

[Comicdey]

Please compare this one to the other and give me an opinion on which one you'd keep of the two?

 

Stain ruins this one and the spine wear is bad on the other.

I gave them both a 5.0.

 

I would sell them both and use the funds to get a nice white page 6.5-7.5.

 

Not an option right now, as I'm keeping one of them. One is for sale....and looks like it'll be the non-water stained issue. Now I just have to figure out a fair price.

 

Thanks for the hilarious feedback on grading.

[burntboy]

i think they'd grade within .5 of each other so i'd keep this one, as the FC is nicer IMHO..................