Please compare these two Caps..

[marvelcollector]

Which is better? Another toss up for me...

 

Copy A

 

 

 

Copy B

 

 

 

Thanks!!

[Mr. Zipper]

Copy A without a doubt.

 

Better cover centering and less edgewear.

[Comicdey]

I'd go with copy a just due to the centering. I think copy b might have better pages though.

[Point Five]

I agree, A due to centering. This is a nice example of an instance where the technical grade of B is probably a bit better, but looking past the grade, A just looks that much tighter with the dead-on centering & no miswrap.

[KingOfRulers]

I agree with everyone else. Copy A is better

[joeypost]

A it is.

[uclapeterg]

I'd go with copy a just due to the centering. I think copy b might have better pages though.

 

I agree with this analysis.

[-cryptkeeper-]

no problem agree with A ? Nice books

[inconceivable]

Copy "A" would grade higher and looks better too. Why the for you?

 

Dan

[marvelcollector]

Copy "A" would grade higher and looks better too. Why the for you?

 

Dan

 

Oddly enough, in hand these two look closer than in the scans....

(Also, oddly enough, they both graded as a consensus 8.0 on the boards... )

 

[Comicdey]

Copy "A" would grade higher and looks better too. Why the for you?

 

Dan

 

Oddly enough, in hand these two look closer than in the scans....

(Also, oddly enough, they both graded as a consensus 8.0 on the boards... )

 

 

Oddly enough, you now have consensus.

 

Keep A, Use B for kindling.

[marvelcollector]

Copy "A" would grade higher and looks better too. Why the for you?

 

Dan

 

Oddly enough, in hand these two look closer than in the scans....

(Also, oddly enough, they both graded as a consensus 8.0 on the boards... )

 

 

Oddly enough, you now have consensus.

 

Keep A, Use B for kindling.

 

Unanimity, actually.

[Kermit the frog]

Copy A without a doubt.

 

Better cover centering and less edgewear.

 

ditto

[Jeffro.]

Copy A without a doubt.

 

Better cover centering and less edgewear.

 

ditto

 

ditto ditto

[ft88]

Copy B if the interior covers on A have a "halo" and B doesn't. Thats a much bigger problem for me than the miswrap.

[burntboy]

Copy "A" would grade higher and looks better too. Why the for you?

 

Dan

 

Oddly enough, in hand these two look closer than in the scans....

(Also, oddly enough, they both graded as a consensus 8.0 on the boards... )

 

 

agree that they are pretty close.

 

but if the concensus was they are the same technical grade, then the copy without the miswrap should be a pretty clear winner................

[rjpb]

Agee with the concensus unless copy B has signicantly superior page quality. Sell them both and buy a copy with the cool blue star shield variant cover.