Guess the Grade GA Archie style

[Scrooge]

2.0

5.5

6.0

[inconceivable]

Pep #23 GD/VG 3.0

Pep #31 FN 6.0

Archie Giant Series #1 VF- 7.5

 

Dan

[Dad&Son-migration]

I'm going to say

 

3.0

6.5

7.0

[Silver]

3.0

5.5

6.5

[MutantKeys]

Wow..Grades are all over the place for these

[rjpb]

I didn't read the part about the 2" stain on the BC of the #31

 

revising my guess to a 6.5.

[nik]

1 3.5

 

2 7.0

 

3 6.0

[143ksk]

Voting will close 12 noon central time tomorrow Saturday the 21st. Get your votes in for a deluxe Archieriffic prize (and, no it's not Pep 23 )

[MutantKeys]

(and, no it's not Pep 23 )

Pep 22

[Comicdey]

is someone already correct?

[joeypost]

2.5

6.5

7.5

[divad]

3.5

 

 

5.5

 

 

8.5

 

 

[-cryptkeeper-]

2.5

6.5

7.0

[Kakapo]

Well, I wanted to say 3.0, 6.0, 7.5 but inconceivable beat me to it. Inconceivable! Thus: 3.0, 6.0, 8.0

[143ksk]

My grade expectations were:

 

3.0

5.5

7.5

 

And the answers are...

 

4.0

5.0

7.5

 

I was very surprised by the 4.0 on the #23 (but pleased )

 

No one got all three correct, but ComicsandCode came closer than I did. So, ComicsandCode, if you PM me your shipping address, I will send you an Archie-type reward.

[divad]

Good work and nice books!

[rjpb]

I was very surprised by the 4.0 on the #23 (but pleased )

 

 

Don't take this wrong, 143ksk, because I'm happy for you, but a 4.0 on that #23 is

 

That's a grade I would expect from a certain dealer who floods ebay on dime listing day.

 

Especially if they're only going to give a 5.0 to your #31

 

That back cover stain must have been pretty bad, because the front looks sweeeet!

[143ksk]

I agree with you on the 4.0. It's a solid book, but I really thought they'd hit it hard for the paint (or whatever it is) on the top left. I'm happy, though. And, yes the stain on the 31 is pretty bad, although I didn't see them knocking it all the way down to 5.0. Oh well...

[Point Five]

Congrats, friend! And whatever the numbers on the label, those are some nice books.

[ComicsAndCode]

My grade expectations were:

 

3.0

5.5

7.5

 

And the answers are...

 

4.0

5.0

7.5

 

I was very surprised by the 4.0 on the #23 (but pleased )

 

No one got all three correct, but ComicsandCode came closer than I did. So, ComicsandCode, if you PM me your shipping address, I will send you an Archie-type reward.

 

Cool, congrats on the Pep 23! I thought the damage at the top left corner would drop it below VG. Peter