PGM Green Lantern 76

[Paratrooper]

This is my third PGM thread. Since I'm planning on joining as a paid member to the "Society" and get my 3 free submissions, I thought I'd post my three top choices to see if its even worth it. Besides my G.I. Combat #78 and Foxhole #2 I am thinking of submitting this issue of GL 76, although having second thoughts about this one as I think it only grades about a 7.5.

[alecholland]

Honestly, I'm not sure about 7.5 on this book. A few too many minor defects IMHO bring the grade down. Quite a bit of spine stress, light color breaking crease right corner, light soiling on back cover, also looks like color rub along spine, and what looks like a tear where green arrow is saying "never again" bring the grade down to about 6.5 at best. I'm not trying to be hard on your book, just think it's more in the Fine range.

[Paratrooper]

Bummer, may just keep it raw then. I'll look through my collection for a third book to grade. Think I may have something neat in there, I'll post one tomorrow.

[flatrock02]

6.0

Back cover and numerous small defects hurt it.

[ashrael]

5.5 or 6.0. The tear and long crease on the front really hurt it.

[divad]

4.0 No way you should ever slab this puppy

 

4" crease LRFC; 3/8" and 1/4" tears at REFC; moderate spine creasing; general soiling; wear at edges and corners . . . book no way, no how grades in the FN range. I'm having trouble seeing a 5.0

[uclapeterg]

4.5.

[mar-vell]

4.0 No way you should ever slab this puppy

 

4" crease LRFC; 3/8" and 1/4" tears at REFC; moderate spine creasing; general soiling; wear at edges and corners . . . book no way, no how grades in the FN range. I'm having trouble seeing a 5.0

 

thanks for setting these guys straight divad! Less work for me

[Paratrooper]

4.0! now I'm not a serious grader but I am 90% sure that this book rates higher than that. I might have to slab it to prove you wrong.....

[Owls Head]

5.0

[Sal]

i think it's a VG/FN, personally. which is a 5.0 to the n00bs.

 

but this book isn't sniffing VF, sad to say. but on the positive side, it's going to hold value for a while

[Paratrooper]

i think it's a VG/FN, personally. which is a 5.0 to the n00bs.

 

but this book isn't sniffing VF, sad to say. but on the positive side, it's going to hold value for a while

 

bummer, knew it was better than a 4.0! It's a pretty 5.0 though, just may not bother upgrading, happy with the way it looks.

[Sal]

i think it's a VG/FN, personally. which is a 5.0 to the n00bs.

 

but this book isn't sniffing VF, sad to say. but on the positive side, it's going to hold value for a while

 

bummer, knew it was better than a 4.0! It's a pretty 5.0 though, just may not bother upgrading, happy with the way it looks.

 

obviously, the most important thing....

[mar-vell]

4.0! now I'm not a serious grader but I am 90% sure that this book rates higher than that. I might have to slab it to prove you wrong.....

 

i was actually thinking 4.5/5.0 but a 4.0 is a WAY closer than anything in the high grade range. Anyone who thinks this is high grade fails the CGC grading forum final exam!

[action1kid]

4.5